Skip to main content
. 2021 Oct 8;39(11):1343–1354. doi: 10.1007/s40273-021-01091-w

Table 4.

Scenario analysis results

Parameter Base-case setting Scenario analysis setting Incremental costs per patient Incremental QALYs per patient Cost per QALY gained per patient
Base case $23,322 0.28 $82,448
Discounting rate per year for costs and clinical outcomes

Costs: 3%

Clinical: 3%

Costs: 0%

Clinical: 0%

$25,911 0.34 $76,049

Costs: 6%

Clinical: 6%

$21,205 0.24 $89,004
Parametric distribution for risk of CV death post HFH Gompertz Weibull $28,546 0.36 $78,946
Gamma $28,745 0.30 $95,164
Daily drug acquisition cost of both vericiguat and sacubitril/valsartan $19.43 with 25% discount ($14.57)a $19.43 with 35% discount ($12.63) $20,321 0.28 $71,839
$19.43 with 30% discount ($13.60) $21,821 0.28 $77,143
$19.43 with 20% discount ($15.54) $24,822 0.28 $87,753
HFH cost per HFH event; routine care cost per month prior to HFH; routine care cost per month post HFH; terminal care cost per mortality event Medicare perspectiveb: $10,419; $287; $624; $9148 Medicare perspective (alternative estimates)c: $13,673; $159; $346; $9148 $22,773 0.28 $80,507
Commercial payer perspectived: $23,605; $307; $668; $31,779 $22,908 0.28 $80,983
$0 for the terminal care cost $23,417 0.28 $82,785

CV cardiovascular, HFH heart failure hospitalization, LYs life-years, PSoCT prior standard-of-care therapies, QALYs quality-adjusted life-years, WHFE worsening heart failure events

aThe daily cost of both sacubitril/valsartan and vericiguat applied in the cost-effectiveness analysis (i.e., $14.57) was estimated as the daily wholesale acquisition cost for sacubitril/valsartan (i.e., $19.43), with an extra 25% discount (assumption)

bIn the base case, the HFH and routine care costs were based on Medicare fee-for-service costs, whereas the terminal care cost was based on Medicare Advantage costs (see Table 2 for more details of base-case input estimates and references)

cThe references and estimation of the alternative Medicare costs applied in the scenario analysis were exactly the same as those adopted for the base-case analysis. The exception is that in the base-case analysis, the HFH and routine care costs were based on Medicare fee-for-service costs, whereas in the scenario analysis, the HFH and routine care costs were based on Medicare Advantage costs

dThe HFH cost of $23,605 was estimated by inflating the HFH cost per admission of $22,050 (2018 US dollars) among Medicare Advantage enrollees with WHFE from Butler et al. [11]. The monthly routine care cost of $307 prior to HFH was estimated by inflating the monthly HF-related outpatient cost of $287 (2018 US dollars) in Medicare Advantage enrollees with WHFE from Butler et al. [11]. Same as the base-case analysis, the monthly cost of routine care in or post HFH was estimated by applying a ratio of 2.17 (per Butler et al. [11]) to the monthly cost prior to HFH. The terminal care cost of $31,779 per mortality event was estimated by inflating the average HF-related medical cost of $26,037 (2013 US dollars) among commercially insured enrollees in their last month before death from Obi et al. [37]