Table 3. Comparisons of major grading standards for liver inflammation.
Score | Knodell’s scoring system |
Score | Scheuer’s scoring system |
|||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Periportal inflammation with or without bridging necrosis | Intralobular degeneration and focal necrosis | Portal inflammation | Portal/periportal activity | Intralobular activity | ||
0 | None | None | None | 0 | None or minimal | None |
1 | Mild piecemeal necrosis | Mild (acidophilic bodies, ballooning degeneration or scattered foci, or both of hepatocellular necrosis in <⅓ of lobules or nodules) | Mild (a few inflammatory cells in <⅓ of portal tracts) | 1 | Portal inflammation alone | Inflammation but no necrosis |
3 | Moderate piecemeal necrosis (involving <50% of the circumference of most portal tracts) | Moderate (involving ⅓–⅓ of lobules or nodules) | Moderate (increased inflammatory cells in ⅓–⅔ of portal tracts) | 2 | Mild piecemeal necrosis | Focal necrosis or acidophilic bodies |
4 | Marked piecemeal necrosis (involving >50% of the circumference of most portal tracts) | Marked (involving >⅔ of lobules or nodules) | Marked (dense inflammatory cells in >⅔ of portal tracts) | 3 | Moderate piecemeal necrosis | Marked focal cell damage |
5 | Moderate piecemeal necrosis plus bridging necrosis | – | – | 4 | Marked piecemeal necrosis | Damage includes bridging necrosis |
6 | Marked piecemeal necrosis plus bridging necrosis | – | – | |||
10 | Multilobular necrosis | – | – |
Score | Wang Tailing’s scoring system |
Score | Ishak’s scoring system |
||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Portal/periportal area | Intralobular area | Portal inflammation | Periportal or periseptal interface inflammation | Focal necrosis, apoptosis, or focal inflammation | Confluent necrosis | ||
0 | No inflammation | No inflammation | 0 | None | None | None | None |
1 | Portal inflammation | Degeneration and a few necrotic foci | 1 | Mild, involving some or all portal areas | Mild (focal, involving few portal areas) | ≤1 foci per 10× objective | Focal confluent necrosis |
2 | Mild piecemeal necrosis | Degeneration, spotted or focal necrosis or acidophilic bodies | 2 | Marked, involving some or all portal areas | Mild/moderate (focal, involving most portal areas) | 2–4 foci per 10× objective | Zone 3 necrosis in some areas |
3 | Moderate piecemeal necrosis | Degeneration, severe necrosis, or bridging necrosis | 3 | Moderate to severe, involving all portal areas | Moderate (continuous around <50% of tracts or septa) | 5–10 foci per 10× objective | Zone 3 necrosis in most areas |
4 | Marked piecemeal necrosis | Bridging necrosis involving multiple lobules | 4 | Severe, involving all portal areas | Severe (continuous around >50% of tracts or septa) | >10 foci per 10× objective | Zone 3 necrosis and occasional portal-central bridging necrosis |
5 | – | – | – | Zone 3 necrosis and multiple portal-central bridging necrosis | |||
6 | – | – | – | Panacinar or multiacinar necrosis |
–, not applicable.