Skip to main content
. 2021 Aug 26;54(5):360–369. doi: 10.3961/jpmph.21.333

Table 2.

Allocation principles and questionnaire used in the survey

Allocation principles1 Survey questionnaire Abbreviation
Maximizing total benefits (utilitarianism)
Save the most lives Resources should be allocated in a way that can save more people SMLV
Save the most life-years Resources should be allocated first to those who can obtain greater health benefits SMLY
Treating people equally (egalitarianism)
First-come, first-served Everyone should be treated equally; Therefore, resource allocation should be done on a first come, first served basis FCFS
Random selection Everyone should be treated equally; Therefore, resource allocation should be done through a lottery RAND
Promoting and rewarding social usefulness
Priority to those who have made relevant contributions (reciprocity) Resources should be allocated first to those who have contributed to the related field, such as medical personnel who participated in the treatment of infectious diseases RCPC
Priority to those who are likely to make relevant contributions (instrumental value) Resources should be allocated first to those who can contribute to related fields in the future, such as medical personnel who can be assigned to treat patients with infectious diseases ISMV
Favoring the worst-off (prioritarianism)
Sickest first Resources should be allocated first to those who are sicker SICK
Youngest first Resources should be allocated first to those who are younger YONG
Favoring people with membership (identity-based allocation)
Koreans first Resources should be allocated first to those with Korean nationality KORN
Compensating for not being responsible (luck-egalitarianism)
Priority to those who are not responsible for the disease (personal responsibility) Resources should be allocated first to those who are not personally responsible for the infection RSPB
1

In addition to the 8 principles reviewed by Emanuel et al. N Engl J Med 2020;382(21):2049-2055 [7], the authors added the principles of “Koreans first” and “personal responsibility.”