Skip to main content
. 2021 Oct 1;12:734217. doi: 10.3389/fphys.2021.734217

Table 1.

Segmentation methods comparison on validation and test dataset.

2D model 3D model
Image Body-nav. Accuracy MaxD Dice Accuracy MaxD Dice
3Dircadb-15 No 0.9898 50.8189 0.9094 0.1340 279.6009 0.1025
3Dircadb-16 No 0.9773 52.0738 0.8713 0.1610 305.2199 0.1498
3Dircadb-17 No 0.9773 54.6727 0.8755 0.1610 269.8953 0.1498
Sliver07-16 No 0.9831 37.2269 0.8912 0.1877 316.4408 0.1944
Sliver07-17 No 0.9911 224.5562 0.8361 0.1414 253.8510 0.1158
Sliver07-18 No 0.9849 250.1329 0.7539 0.1359 284.2670 0.1059
3Dircadb-18 No 0.9732 79.9842 0.8892 0.1528 335.1785 0.1356
3Dircadb-19 No 0.9678 71.5489 0.7918 0.1032 406.9116 0.0453
3Dircadb-20 No 0.9851 50.0576 0.8815 0.1032 304.3232 0.0453
Sliver07-19 No 0.9616 118.8727 0.7853 0.1504 274.8742 0.1315
Sliver07-20 No 0.9731 245.2699 0.7165 0.1141 274.7924 0.0660
Avg. value No 0.9786 131.9546 0.8240 0.1404 300.4868 0.1129
St. dev. No 0.0092 85.0098 0.0646 0.0250 40.3931 0.0445
3Dircadb-15 Yes 0.9871 34.0230 0.8897 0.9746 100.6067 0.7981
3Dircadb-16 Yes 0.9706 31.3055 0.8118 0.9576 88.0981 0.7201
3Dircadb-17 Yes 0.9780 53.7383 0.8799 0.9675 128.1953 0.8191
Sliver07-16 Yes 0.9818 33.5785 0.8801 0.9545 90.1366 0.7766
Sliver07-17 Yes 0.9931 45.1112 0.8695 0.9633 83.2325 0.7538
Sliver07-18 Yes 0.9928 151.0889 0.8645 0.9565 139.8558 0.6247
3Dircadb-18 Yes 0.9761 41.7075 0.8964 0.9680 93.3783 0.7934
3Dircadb-19 Yes 0.9721 46.9303 0.8146 0.9868 69.3535 0.7698
3Dircadb-20 Yes 0.9817 48.7038 0.8584 0.9872 99.6428 0.7317
Sliver07-19 Yes 0.9693 57.9692 0.8209 0.9624 83.0969 0.7634
Sliver07-20 Yes 0.9829 187.7416 0.7968 0.9860 65.3701 0.8196
Avg. value Yes 0.9816 75.4617 0.8509 0.9695 94.6333 0.7609
St. dev. Yes 0.0083 52.1915 0.0353 0.0118 21.4375 0.0528

All the values are without post-processing.