Skip to main content
. 2021 May 17;109(12):1967–1985. doi: 10.1002/jbm.b.34861

TABLE 2.

Summary of advantages and disadvantages of several wound dressings

Advantages Disadvantages
Contact layer
  • Low adherence24

  • Used with secondary dressing24,26

  • May adhere to wound bed when dry29

  • Permeable to bacteria27

Semipermeable film
  • Permeable to gases27

  • Effects growth of anaerobic bacteria24

  • Facilitates autolytic debridement24

  • Impermeable to bacteria27

  • Can be used with secondary dressing

  • Maintains moist wound environment

  • Nonabsorbent

  • Traps underlying exudate24

  • If unchanged, aids bacterial overgrowth in moist environment25

Hydrocolloid
  • Maintains moist wound environment by gelling with exudate27

  • Facilitates autolytic debridement27

  • Forms a thick, yellow malodorous gel36

Hydrogel
  • Maintains moist wound environment28,36

  • Cooling effect when applied28,36

  • Used with secondary dressing36

  • Multiple forms are available36

  • Low absorptive capacity28

  • Exudate accumulation can lead to wound maceration and bacterial proliferation34

Foam
  • Absorbent50

  • Different forms are available50

  • Protects wound from trauma26

  • Provides thermal insultation26

  • Can be combined with NPWT50

  • Risk of drying in wounds with low exudate28

NPWT
  • Brings wound edges together57

  • Stimulates fibroblasts57

  • Stimulates granulation, particularly angiogenesis57

  • Stimulates epithelial proliferation when used with liner (Prevena™)57

  • Various contraindications59

Antimicrobial dressings
  • Prevents wound contamination54

Abbreviation: NPWT, negative pressure wound therapy.