Skip to main content
. 2021 Oct 18;2021(10):CD012679. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD012679.pub2

1. Description of screening tests.

    Tests (percentage)
(n = 37 tests)
Complete or narrative Complete ‐ 2 × 2 table data extracted 33 (89%)
  Narrative ‐ 2 × 2 table data not available 4 (11%)
Participants
Na Median (IQR) 100 (50 to 161) Min = 22, max = 300
N with dysphagia/aspirationa Median (IQR) 38 (17 to 63) Min = 8, max = 106
Mean age Median (IQR) 67.6 (64.75 to 71.4) Min = 58.6, max = 76.8
Sex % male Median (IQR) 54.7 (49 to 65.6) Min = 35, max = 100
Year recruitment started   Min = 1995, max = 2016
Country UK and Europe 8 (22%)
USA and Canada 22 (59%)
Other 6 (16%)
Not recorded 1 (3%)
Study design
Admission to index test ≤ 24 hours 16 (43%)
> 24 hours and < 72 hours 6 (16%)
≥ 72 hours 2 (5%)
Not recorded 13 (35%)
Order tests applied Index then reference 28 (76%)
Reference then index 1 (3%)
Mixed or not specified 5 (14%)
Not recorded 3 (8%)
Index/reference time interval ≤ 24 hours 18 (49%)
> 24 hours 10 (27%)
Not recorded 9 (24%)
Index test training given Yes 21 (57%)
Not recorded 16 (43%)
Index test type Water only 24 (65%)
Water plus other consistencies 6 (16%)
Other 7 (19%)
Index test HCP Nurse 21 (57%)
Other 16 (43%)
Outcome Aspiration 15 (41%)
Dysphagia 20 (54%)
NR 2 (5%)
Reference test Expert assessment and MASA 20 (54%)
FEES 6 (16%)
VF 11 (30%)

aUsing complete studies only.
FEES: fibreoptic endoscopic evaluation of swallowing.
HCP: healthcare professional.
IQR: interquartile range.
MASA: Mann Assessment of Swallowing Ability.
VF: videofluoroscopy.