Study | Reason for exclusion |
---|---|
Addington 1999 Study 1 | No acute stroke |
Addington 1999 Study 2 | No acute stroke |
Alsibai 2014 | No outcome of interest |
Anderson 2016 | Does not compare tests |
Archer 2015 Study 1 | No index or reference test of interest |
Archer 2015 Study 2 | No index or reference test of interest |
Armesto 2015 | No outcome of interest |
Aviv 1997 | No outcome of interest |
Aydogdu 2015 | Not limited to stroke patients |
Babi 2014 | Does not compare tests |
Bahia 2014 | Does not compare tests |
Bahia 2016 | Not an acute setting |
Bax 2013 | Does not compare tests |
Bax 2014 | No index or reference test of interest |
Benjamin 2015 | Not a single‐gate or 2‐gate study |
Burks 2011 | No screening for dysphagia |
Carnaby 2014 | No index or reference test of interest |
Carrington 2013 | Does not compare tests |
Chavarria 2015 | No screening for dysphagia |
Choi 2010 | No index or reference test of interest |
Chong 2003 | Not an acute setting |
Cichero 2009 | Not limited to stroke patients |
Clayton 2006 | No index or reference test of interest |
Collins 1997 | Not an acute setting |
Crary 2013 Study 1 | No index or reference test of interest |
Crary 2013 Study 2 | No index or reference test of interest |
Crary 2014 Study 1 | No index or reference test of interest |
Crary 2014 Study 2 | No index or reference test of interest |
Daniels 2009 | Does not compare tests |
Davis‐De Geus 2009 | No outcome of interest |
DePippo 1992 | Not an acute setting |
Farneti 2015 | Index test undertaken by experts |
Giraldo‐Cadavid 2015 | No outcome of interest |
Guerra 2011 | Does not compare tests |
Guillén‐Solà 2011 | No screening for dysphagia |
Guillén‐Solà 2013 | Not an acute setting |
Gurcay 2018 | Sample not restricted to acute stages of stroke |
Higo 2003 | No index or reference test of interest |
Joundi 2017 | Not a single‐gate or 2‐gate study |
Karaca 2018 | Reference test MASA considered an SLT dysphagia assessment |
Logemann 1999 | Not limited to stroke patients |
Mandysova 2015 | Not limited to stroke patients |
Marques 2008 | Does not compare tests |
Martino 2009 Study 2 | No index or reference test of interest |
Massey 2002 | Not all patients received the same reference test |
McCullough 2001 | SLT dysphagia assessment, not screening |
McCullough 2005 | No acute stroke |
Moalli 2016 | Does not compare tests |
Moon 2010 | No consecutive stroke patients |
Mozzanica 2017 | Heterogeneous population. Stroke not analysed separately |
Murray 2011 | No outcome of interest |
NCT00306501 | No accuracy of screening |
NCT00580138 | No index or reference test of interest |
NCT01765673 | No accuracy of screening |
NCT02080988 | No outcome of interest |
NCT02848664 | Not limited to stroke patients |
NCT03167892 | No accuracy of screening |
Nomura 2014 | Does not compare tests |
Oh 2016 | All patients had dysphagia or aspiration; therefore sensitivity/specificity cannot be calculated |
Ohira 2013 | Not limited to stroke patients |
Ohira 2017 | Not an acute setting |
Osawa 2013 | No consecutive stroke patients |
Ostrofsky 2016 | Index tests carried out by SLT/SLP |
Palli 2017 | No reference test performed on same patients who had nurse swallow screen – the comparison was with case note data from historic SLT assessment |
Pennsylvania Patient Safety Authority 2009 | Not limited to stroke patients |
Perry 2000 | Does not compare tests |
Perry 2001 Study 2 | Does not compare tests |
Radhakrishnan 2013 | No screening for dysphagia |
Rosenbek 2004 | SLT dysphagia assessment, not screening |
Sato 2012 | Not an acute setting |
Schrock 2011 | No index or reference test of interest |
Sellars 1998 | All patients had dysphagia or aspiration; therefore sensitivity/specificity cannot be calculated |
Smith Hammond 2009 | Index tests carried out by SLT/SLP |
Sohn 2018 | Reference test is a retrospective evaluation of case records |
Soria 2013 | Not limited to stroke patients |
Stroke and Chewing 2012 | No outcome of interest |
Sung 2018 | Does not compare tests |
Sørensen 2013 | Does not compare tests |
Tanuma 2002 | Not screening for dysphagia |
Teramoto 2000 | Not an acute setting |
Toscano 2019 | Index test undertaken by experts |
Tuncay 2011 | Not index or reference test of interest |
Umay 2013 | No acute stroke |
Virvidaki 2019 | Index test undertaken by experts |
Warnecke 2017 | Index tests carried out by SLT/SLP |
Weinhardt 2008 | Does not compare tests |
Ye 2018 | No reference test was included |
Yeh 2011 | Does not compare tests |
Zhang 2004 | All patients had dysphagia or aspiration; therefore sensitivity/specificity cannot be calculated |
MASA: Mann Assessment of Swallowing Ability. SLP: speech and language pathologist. SLT: speech and language therapist.