Skip to main content
. 2021 Oct 18;2021(10):CD012679. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD012679.pub2
Study Reason for exclusion
Addington 1999 Study 1 No acute stroke
Addington 1999 Study 2 No acute stroke
Alsibai 2014 No outcome of interest
Anderson 2016 Does not compare tests
Archer 2015 Study 1 No index or reference test of interest
Archer 2015 Study 2 No index or reference test of interest
Armesto 2015 No outcome of interest
Aviv 1997 No outcome of interest
Aydogdu 2015 Not limited to stroke patients
Babi 2014 Does not compare tests
Bahia 2014 Does not compare tests
Bahia 2016 Not an acute setting
Bax 2013 Does not compare tests
Bax 2014 No index or reference test of interest
Benjamin 2015 Not a single‐gate or 2‐gate study
Burks 2011 No screening for dysphagia
Carnaby 2014 No index or reference test of interest
Carrington 2013 Does not compare tests
Chavarria 2015 No screening for dysphagia
Choi 2010 No index or reference test of interest
Chong 2003 Not an acute setting
Cichero 2009 Not limited to stroke patients
Clayton 2006 No index or reference test of interest
Collins 1997 Not an acute setting
Crary 2013 Study 1 No index or reference test of interest
Crary 2013 Study 2 No index or reference test of interest
Crary 2014 Study 1 No index or reference test of interest
Crary 2014 Study 2 No index or reference test of interest
Daniels 2009 Does not compare tests
Davis‐De Geus 2009 No outcome of interest
DePippo 1992 Not an acute setting
Farneti 2015 Index test undertaken by experts
Giraldo‐Cadavid 2015 No outcome of interest
Guerra 2011 Does not compare tests
Guillén‐Solà 2011 No screening for dysphagia
Guillén‐Solà 2013 Not an acute setting
Gurcay 2018 Sample not restricted to acute stages of stroke
Higo 2003 No index or reference test of interest
Joundi 2017 Not a single‐gate or 2‐gate study
Karaca 2018 Reference test MASA considered an SLT dysphagia assessment
Logemann 1999 Not limited to stroke patients
Mandysova 2015 Not limited to stroke patients
Marques 2008 Does not compare tests
Martino 2009 Study 2 No index or reference test of interest
Massey 2002 Not all patients received the same reference test
McCullough 2001 SLT dysphagia assessment, not screening
McCullough 2005 No acute stroke
Moalli 2016 Does not compare tests
Moon 2010 No consecutive stroke patients
Mozzanica 2017 Heterogeneous population. Stroke not analysed separately
Murray 2011 No outcome of interest
NCT00306501 No accuracy of screening
NCT00580138 No index or reference test of interest
NCT01765673 No accuracy of screening
NCT02080988 No outcome of interest
NCT02848664 Not limited to stroke patients
NCT03167892 No accuracy of screening
Nomura 2014 Does not compare tests
Oh 2016 All patients had dysphagia or aspiration; therefore sensitivity/specificity cannot be calculated
Ohira 2013 Not limited to stroke patients
Ohira 2017 Not an acute setting
Osawa 2013 No consecutive stroke patients
Ostrofsky 2016 Index tests carried out by SLT/SLP
Palli 2017 No reference test performed on same patients who had nurse swallow screen – the comparison was with case note data from historic SLT assessment
Pennsylvania Patient Safety Authority 2009 Not limited to stroke patients
Perry 2000 Does not compare tests
Perry 2001 Study 2 Does not compare tests
Radhakrishnan 2013 No screening for dysphagia
Rosenbek 2004 SLT dysphagia assessment, not screening
Sato 2012 Not an acute setting
Schrock 2011 No index or reference test of interest
Sellars 1998 All patients had dysphagia or aspiration; therefore sensitivity/specificity cannot be calculated
Smith Hammond 2009 Index tests carried out by SLT/SLP
Sohn 2018 Reference test is a retrospective evaluation of case records
Soria 2013 Not limited to stroke patients
Stroke and Chewing 2012 No outcome of interest
Sung 2018 Does not compare tests
Sørensen 2013 Does not compare tests
Tanuma 2002 Not screening for dysphagia
Teramoto 2000 Not an acute setting
Toscano 2019 Index test undertaken by experts
Tuncay 2011 Not index or reference test of interest
Umay 2013 No acute stroke
Virvidaki 2019 Index test undertaken by experts
Warnecke 2017 Index tests carried out by SLT/SLP
Weinhardt 2008 Does not compare tests
Ye 2018 No reference test was included
Yeh 2011 Does not compare tests
Zhang 2004 All patients had dysphagia or aspiration; therefore sensitivity/specificity cannot be calculated

MASA: Mann Assessment of Swallowing Ability.
SLP: speech and language pathologist.
SLT: speech and language therapist.