Table 1.
Method | Culture cell types | Viability | Proliferation | Differentiation | Time length | Spheroid diameter (μm) | Advantages | Disadvantages | Refs. |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Liquid overlay | (1) MDPSCs; (2) ADSCs | Well-preserved | Osteogenic | -1 day | 30-100 | (1) Simple; (2) economical | Size of the spheroids cannot be controlled | [15–21] | |
Hanging drop culture | WJ-MSCs | Cell death rate was below 40% | Higher than 2D |
Early osteogenic | Depend on cell types | Controllable | Uniformity | Volume cannot more than 30 μL | [2, 22–27] |
Rotating bioreactor | BMSCs | High level of viability | Osteoblastic | 1 day | 100–200 | (1) Simple; (2) efficient | (1) Shear stress; (2) equipment | [18, 28] | |
Magnetic suspension | NIH3T3 | 99% cell viability | Exponential growth | 5 minutes | (1) Repeatable ability; (2) size stability. | Potential impact of nanoparticles is uncertain | [24, 29–34] | ||
Chemical reagents culture | ADSCs | High level of viability | Suppressed | Osteogenesis | 3-4 days | 50-200 | (1) Simple; (2) practical; (3) special equipment unnecessary | Potential impacts of reagent are uncertain | [6, 35] |
Alginate-PEG gels | mMSCs | Improves the viability of cell | Reducing cellular apoptosis | Osteogenic | Biocompatibility high mechanical strength | Early complicate | [36–57] |