Table 5.
Wilcoxon test results for the numerical results of various FLAT versions against BPINF.
| PSO | IMO | IMO-PSO | SCA | ASCA-PSO | BA | BA-DE | BA-CSA | BA-PSO-1 | BA-PSO-2 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 250,000 | 4.0E-06 | 2.5E-05 | 2.8E-07 | 7.7E-06 | 3.9E-07 | 2.1E-06 | 2.0E-06 | 1.3E-05 | 2.5E-06 | 3.5E-05 |
| 350,000 | 1.4E-06 | 3.2E-06 | 1.8E-06 | 4.7E-06 | 2.3E-06 | 2.6E-06 | 1.6E-07 | 1.5E-06 | 2.9E-07 | 1.9E-06 |
| 550,000 | 8.5E-07 | 4.6E-05 | 1.0E-06 | 5.8E-06 | 8.0E-08 | 2.2E-06 | 3.2E-07 | 3.1E-05 | 2.5E-06 | 3.4E-05 |
| 750,000 | 5.5E-06 | 2.9E-06 | 5.5E-07 | 1.1E-05 | 3.8E-08 | 1.7E-06 | 3.5E-05 | 2.0E-05 | 7.7E-05 | 6.6E-05 |
| 1,000,000 | 1.2E-05 | 4.1E-07 | 2.6E-07 | 2.3E-05 | 2.4E-07 | 1.5E-06 | 5.1E-06 | 3.9E-07 | 7.0E-06 | 4.1E-07 |
| 1,400,000 | 6.2E-06 | 3.2E-06 | 5.9E-06 | 1.3E-05 | 2.4E-06 | 9.5E-06 | 1.6E-06 | 2.2E-05 | 3.5 E-06 | 2.3E-05 |
| 1,800,000 | 9.1E-07 | 4.5E-06 | 8.1E-07 | 1.5E-06 | 3.5E-07 | 1.2E-06 | 2.2E-07 | 4.5E-05 | 4.2E-07 | 5.6E-05 |
| 2,200,000 | 1.3E-06 | 1.0E-05 | 1.0E-08 | 1.9E-06 | 1.3E-07 | 1.2E-06 | 1.7E-04 | 2.8E-06 | 3.3E-04 | 4.6E-06 |
| 2,600,000 | 4.7E-06 | 3.8E-05 | 2.5E-06 | 2.8E-05 | 1.2E-06 | 2.9E-06 | 4.8E-05 | 2.6E-04 | 7.1E-05 | 6.2E-04 |
| 3,000,000 | 5.2E-07 | 1.4E-06 | 1.4E-07 | 1.4E-06 | 1.5E-07 | 1.2E-06 | 2.5E-05 | 2.0E-07 | 7.0E-05 | 5.0E-07 |
| 4,000,000 | 1.0E-05 | 1.5E-06 | 1.2E-06 | 1.4E-05 | 3.3E-07 | 1.3E-06 | 2.2E-07 | 6.9E-05 | 7.0E-06 | 7.1E-05 |
| 5,000,000 | 1.1E-06 | 9.5E-06 | 1.8E-06 | 2.4E-06 | 9.7E-07 | 1.9E-06 | 3.0E-04 | 2.3E-07 | 3.5E-04 | 6.3E-07 |
| 6,000,000 | 6.3E-05 | 7.7E-05 | 3.4E-07 | 8.0E-05 | 1.8E-08 | 5.1E-07 | 2.9E-05 | 3.9E-05 | 7.0E-05 | 4.5E-05 |
| 7,000,000 | 9.1E-07 | 1.8E-06 | 1.3E-07 | 1.2E-06 | 4.9E-07 | 1.2E-06 | 3.2E-06 | 5.0E-07 | 7.0E-06 | 5.3E-07 |
| 8,000,000 | 6.0E-07 | 5.6E-07 | 3.4E-07 | 2.3E-06 | 2.1E-08 | 4.5E-07 | 1.2E-05 | 4.4E-04 | 6.0E-05 | 5.3E-04 |
| 9,000,000 | 6.5E-06 | 5.9E-06 | 4.0E-08 | 8.4E-05 | 4.7E-07 | 1.4E-06 | 7.3E-07 | 1.4E-05 | 3.7E-06 | 4.3E-05 |
| 11,000,000 | 6.9E-07 | 3.5 E-06 | 8.5E-06 | 2.2E-06 | 5.1E-06 | 1.3E-05 | 9.5E-07 | 2.2E-06 | 2.1E-06 | 2.4E-06 |
| 13,000,000 | 2.3E-07 | 4.0E-07 | 2.8E-07 | 2.7E-07 | 4.0E-07 | 2.5E-06 | 1.8E-08 | 1.7E-05 | 3.5E-06 | 3.2E-05 |
| 15,000,000 | 6.2E-06 | 3.3E-04 | 3.8E-07 | 1.5E-05 | 8.9E-08 | 3.9E-07 | 3.5E-07 | 4.9E-04 | 4.3E-06 | 5.3E-04 |
| 18,000,000 | 6.0E-07 | 1.6E-06 | 9.8E-06 | 1.4E-06 | 5.3E-06 | 2.8E-05 | 2.8E-06 | 1.8E-05 | 5.3E-06 | 4.3E-05 |
| 21,000,000 | 3.2E-06 | 1.8E-06 | 1.0E-07 | 1.7E-05 | 4.5E-08 | 1.4E-07 | 9.3E-07 | 1.3E-04 | 1.6E-06 | 2.3E-04 |