Table 1.
Author(s), year of publication, study design | Plant name and type of extraction | Country participant description, no. of dropouts | Duration and type of treatment | Study outcome | Brief methods, e.g., blood test |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Mayasari et al., 2018 | Rosella with stevia | Yogyakarta, Indonesia | 14-day treatment | Posttreatment | Venous blood samples collected for FBG and 2-hour PBG |
Quasi-experimental research study | As ready-to-brew rosella-stevia bags | 24 prediabetic women | (1) Fast for 8 hours the night before the first day of treatment, to withdraw participants' blood for fasting blood glucose readings | Tea consumption significantly lower FBG level but not the 2-hour PBG level | |
(i) 5 g rosella powder | |||||
(ii) 125 mg stevia sweetener | Aged 30–60 years | ||||
2 groups (control and treatment group) | (2) Each participant was given 75 g sugar in 250 ml water and rested for 2 hours, for 2nd blood withdrawal as 2-hour postprandial blood glucose | ||||
Each rosella-stevia tea bag is brewed with 250 ml of boiling water for 5 mins and cooled down for 20–30 minutes before consuming | 3 dropouts (80% less compliance) | (3) Treatment group | |||
(i) Ready-to-brew rosella-stevia tea 2x per day for 14 days | |||||
| |||||
Dans et al., 2007 | M. charantia (Bitter melon) | Manila, Philippines | 3-month treatment: | No significant effect on mean FBG, total cholesterol, and weight or on serum creatinine, ALT, AST, sodium, and potassium | Each monthly visit: |
Randomized double-blind, placebo-controlled trial | As charantia ampalaya capsules vs. placebo capsules | 40 patients with newly diagnosed or poorly controlled type 2 diabetes with A1c levels between 7% and 9% | (1) M. charantia capsules or placebo: | (i) Capillary blood sugar levels | |
(i) 2 capsules, 3 times per day after meals for 3 months | (ii) Interviewed on compliance and adverse events | ||||
Aged 18 years and above | (ii) Monthly follow-ups | (iii) Diet and medications reinforced | |||
Lab test: | |||||
(i) HbA1C | |||||
(ii) Fasting blood glucose | |||||
(iii) Serum cholesterol | |||||
(iv) Weight | |||||
Extra: | |||||
(i) Serum creatinine, AST, ALT, sodium, potassium | |||||
Adverse events | |||||
| |||||
Sukandar et al., 2014 | Curcuma longa (turmeric) with A. sativum L. (garlic) | Bandung, Indonesia | For 12-week treatment: | (i) Significant decrease in FBG of AC group (192.76 vs. 141.71 mg/dL) and 2 hours postprandial blood glucose (295.35 vs. 204.35 mg/dL) | Evaluated every 2 weeks for 12 weeks |
Double-blind, randomized control trial | As drug (allium curcuma) in the form of capsules: | 36 patients with type 2 diabetes (males and females) aged over 35 years | (1) AC group: | (i) Fasting blood glucose | |
(i) 200 mg of turmeric ethanolic extract, 200 mg of garlic aqueous extract | (i) Random blood glucose at least 200 mg/dL, fasting blood glucose level at least 126 mg/dL with or without dyslipidemia | (i) 2.4 g Allium curcuma capsules | (Ii) 2 hours postprandial | ||
Vs. | (ii) 2 times, 3 capsules per day after meal | (iii) Lipid profile examination | |||
Oral drug | (2) Glibenclamide group: | (ii) Significant decrease in HbAlC 10.41 vs. 8.09) | On week 2 and week 14, examination on: | ||
(ii) 5 mg glibenclamide | 2 groups | (iii) 2 times 3 capsules per day | (iv) HbA1C. Fasting insulin, liver function, renal function, complete hematology, urine and heart function | ||
AC group = 17 | (iv) But for morning after meal, each consumed 1 capsule of 5 mg glibenclamide, and 2 capsules as placebo | ||||
Glibenclamide group = 12 | (v) Evening after meal, each consumed 2 placebo capsules |
Data extracted from each study include title, author(s), journal, year and country of publication, study characteristics (study design, study duration), characteristics of participants (gender, age, sample size), plant type and extractions, intervention (type of treatment) and control used, number of dropouts, methods, and results from the studies.