Skip to main content
. 2021 Sep 16;12:33. doi: 10.4103/jpi.jpi_95_20

Table 4.

Comparison of the current study with the major published whole-slide imaging studies for frozen section diagnosis in literature

Reference, year Number of cases Scanner Diagnostic accuracy (%) Observer variability Cohen’s kappa (K) Mean scanning time (range) Mean reporting time (range)
Tsuchihashi et al., 2008 15 Vassalo 100 N/S N/P 10 min (N/S) 5 min (N/S)
Slodkowska et al., 2009 33 Aperio scan scope 100 Inter-observer N/P N/S (2-7 min) N/S (1-2 min)
Fallon et al., 2010 52 Mirax Desk 96 Inter-observer N/P 9 (1-20 min) N/S (3-5 min)
Ramey et al., 2011 67 Aperio scan scope 89 Inter-observer 0.85 3 (1-9 min) 1 (30 s-13 min)
Gould et al., 2012 30 Nanozoomer 2.0 96.7 Inter-observer N/P N/S N/S
Perron et al., 2014 104 Nanozoomer 2.0 98.1 Inter-observer N/P 5 min (1-25 min) 1 min (1-10 min)
Ribback et al., 2014 1204 Mirax Desk 98.6 Intra-observer N/P 11 min (3-19 min)
Bauer et al., 2015 70 Aperio CS2 95.7 Intra-observer N/P N/S N/S
Yu et al., 2017 100 Aperio AT2 1:61 2:74
3:87 4:75
Inter-observer N/P N/S N/S
Cima et al.,2018 125 Navigo 97 Intra-observer 0.96 12 min 3 min
Present study 2020 60 Grundium Ocus® 95 Inter-observer and intra-observer Inter: 0.915
Intra: 0.905
H and E: 1 min 47 s
TOLB: 1 min 46 s
1 min 8 s

N/P: Not performed, N/S: Not specified, TOLB: Toluidine blue