Table 1:
Summary of Dopamine Sensing Modalities
Modality | Description | Spatial Resolution / Level of Analysis | Temporal Resolution | Advantages | Limitations |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Microdialysis | A small dialysis probe is surgically implanted into the brain and analytes are collected over time | mm-cm / brain regions (e.g. dorsal lateral striatum) | seconds - minutes | HPLC separation allows complete analysis of small molecules within dialysate; can be used in an awake, behaving, free moving animal | Poor spatiotemporal resolution |
FSCV | A redox electrode is inserted into slice or surgically implanted and the concentration of dopamine is electrochemically measured | mm / brain region; specific circuits if coupled with electro- or optogenetic stimulation | milliseconds | High temporal resolution; can be used in acute brain slice or behaving animals | Poor spatial resolution; difficult to implement in vivo |
Fluorescent Microscopy | Small molecule- or protein-based sensors are used to indirectly monitor or measure dopamine release in slice or culture | μm - mm / synapses (e.g. release sites, cell bodies and projections) | milliseconds - seconds | High spatiotemporal resolution; diverse set of fluorescent dyes and protein sensors | Low biopenetrance and small wavelengths can be phototoxic; limited use in vivo |
2P Microscopy | Fluorescent sensors are imaged using two-photon excitation, typically at twice the wavelength | μm - mm / synapses | milliseconds - seconds | Longer wavelengths used in 2P allow higher biopenetrance and less phototoxicity; in vivo imaging is possible | Expensive and complicated to implement; biopenetrance is still limited to 10s – 100s of μm; incompatible with FRET sensors |
Fiber Photometry | A fiberglass fluorescence probe is surgically implanted into the brain; changes in fluorescence intensity of genetic probes are measured over time | mm / brain region; specific circuits | milliseconds - seconds | Protein sensors can be used in vivo in behaving animals; widely adaptable in labs already measuring GCaMP | Limited spatial resolution |
PET | Positron-emitting ligands can target specific receptors in order to monitor dopaminergic activity | mm / brain region | minutes | High sensitivity (i.e. small amount of ligand needed) with a diverse set of ligands; can be used in humans and coupled with behavior | Ligands are expensive, difficult to synthesize, and can have short half-lives; poor spatiotemporal resolution, impossible to resolve ligand signal from its metabolite signal |
MRI | Magnetic resonance is used to image endogenous dopamine metabolites or exogenous MR-active ligands | sub-mm - mm | milliseconds - seconds | Potentially non-invasive, can be used in humans and coupled with behavior; ligands can be used to increase spatiotemporal resolution or highlight specific structures | Information is largely structural and not functional |
MRS | Magnetic resonance is used to generate spectra that can identify specific metabolites and their relative concentrations | mm-cm | seconds - minutes | Can identify and resolve multiple molecules and their relative concentrations within the same voxel, including ligands from their respective metabolites | Highly specialized technique, lower spatiotemporal resolution than MRI and PET; certain nuclides (13C, 15N, and 31P) can have very long scan times |