Table 1.
Title, goal of related work, number of horses in the dataset, sensors and methods proposed in this paper with related work. What makes our research unique is the accurate detection of a the high number of relevant jumping and dressage training activities by automatically extracting features with a CNN using accelerometer data of two legs. NN = Neural Network, DT = Decision Trees, k-NN = k-Nearest Neighbors, NB = Naive Bayes, CNN = Convolutional Neural Network, LDA = linear discriminant analysis, QDA = quadratic discriminant analysis, RF = Random Forest, SVM = Support Vector Machine, LSTM = Long short-term memory, BT = Boosted Trees, GPR = Gaussian Progress Regression.
| Paper | Goal | Number of Horses |
Sensors | Classification Approach |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| [5] | Detection of walk, trot and canter | 2 | Accelerometer | NN, DT, k-NN and NB |
| [6] | Standing, grazing and ambulating | 6 | Accelerometer | Threshold based |
| [11,14] | Detection of stand, walk, trot, canter, roll, paw, flank-watching | 6 | Accelerometer | CNN |
| [15] | Detection of stand, walk, trot and canter | 20 | Accelerometer | Threshold based |
| [7] | Walk, trot, left canter, right canter, tölt, pace, trocha and paso fino | 120 | Accelerometer + gyroscope | LDA, QDA, DT, RF, SVM, NN and LSTM |
| [16] | Estimation of speed in canter | 58 | Accelerometer + gyroscope | SVM |
| [17] | Estimation of speed in walk, trot, tölt, pace and canter | 40 | Accelerometer + gyroscope | SVM, DT, RF, BT, GPR |
| [18] | Presence/absence and degree of lameness | 175 | Camera | NN |
| [4,9,19] | Detection of collected, working, medium and extended pace | 6 | Camera | Threshold based |
| [10] | Detection of trot, piaffe and passage | 10 | Camera | DA |
| [20] | Gait analysis | 35 | Strain gauge | NN |
| [21] | Hoof wall deformation to determine ground reaction forces | 1 | Strain gauge | NN |
| [22] | Prediction of load in long bone | 9 | Strain gauge | NN |
| [23] | Load-displacement in long bone | 13 | Strain gauge | NN |
| This paper | 6 jumping and 25 dressage training activities | 14 | Accelerometer | Hybrid CNN |