Table 6.
Author |
Type of publication |
Design |
Sample |
Outcomes |
Intervention |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Allen (1981) |
Report |
Pre‐post design. It is unclear if the study uses random allocation of participants. |
12 seventh grade teachers |
Disciplinary referrals Corporal punishment School suspensions |
Positive approach to discipline (PAD) is a system of classroom management, incorporating counselling, problem‐solving, and time‐out centres. |
Forbes (1996) |
Thesis |
Pre‐post design. It is unclear if the study uses random allocation of participants. |
900 students (grades six to eight) |
School infractions Out‐of‐school suspension |
Social skills training |
Foster (2011) |
Book |
No information |
African American boys in elementary classrooms |
No information |
Social Skills Curriculum |
Conference proceedings |
Intervention is given to some students, but not to others. Unclear if it is RCT. |
Middle and high school students |
School absences Suspension/expulsion Disciplinary actions Attendance Grades |
School Probation Officer Programme is aimed at identifying juveniles who may be at‐risk of engaging in delinquent behaviour |
|
Gallegos (1998) |
Book |
Review of interventions |
Unclear |
Suspensions Expulsion Dropout school |
Not given |
Neise (1983) |
Thesis |
Two treatment groups and one control group. Unclear if they were randomly allocated in conditions |
37 middle school students |
The Devereaux Adolescent Behaviour Rating Scale (DABRS) The Behaviour Rating Scale (BRS) Seventh hour In‐school suspension Out‐of‐school suspension |
Group counselling methods that used interpersonal problem solving strategies versus non‐directive counselling |
Norris (2009) |
Conference proceedings |
Evaluation |
Unclear |
Suspension Expulsion |
Restorative justice |
Spillman (1993) |
Thesis |
Unclear |
Ninth grade students |
Achievement Motivation Attendance Suspension rate |
Interdisciplinary teaming and parent contacts |