Skip to main content
. 2021 Sep 30;23(10):1293. doi: 10.3390/e23101293

Table 2.

Comparison between the 1D-SE-ResNet and conventional models in terms of average Accuracy (Acc), Precision (Pre), Sensitivity (Sen), and Specificity (Spe). The standardization and smoothing is denoted as std and sm, respectively.

Model Preprocessing Acc of Test Set (%) Acc
(%)
Pre
(%)
Sen
(%)
Spe
(%)
D1 D2 D3 D4 D5 D6 D7 D8
SVM / 92.86 96.67 79.31 78.57 100.0 92.59 90.00 93.33 90.42 94.86 86.03 95.00
std 92.86 96.67 79.31 82.14 96.30 92.59 93.33 93.33 90.82 96.08 86.03 95.63
sm 92.86 96.67 79.31 82.14 92.59 92.59 86.67 93.33 89.52 94.23 86.03 92.92
PCA 92.86 96.67 79.31 75.00 100.0 92.59 90.00 93.33 89.97 93.75 86.03 94.17
RF / 85.71 90.00 75.86 71.43 81.48 92.59 93.33 93.33 85.47 88.47 83.40 87.50
std 85.71 90.00 75.86 71.43 81.48 92.59 93.33 93.33 85.47 88.47 83.40 87.50
sm 85.71 93.33 75.86 75.00 85.19 96.30 100.0 93.33 88.09 92.03 85.06 90.83
PCA 89.29 80.00 75.86 75.00 85.19 92.59 83.33 90.00 83.91 86.85 82.82 85.00
PLS-DA / 96.43 53.33 79.31 67.86 66.67 100.0 83.33 86.67 79.20 81.11 86.03 71.46
std 96.43 53.33 79.31 67.86 66.67 100.0 83.33 86.67 79.20 81.11 86.03 71.46
sm 96.43 80.00 86.21 71.43 96.30 100.0 86.67 96.67 89.21 89.35 89.36 88.96
1D-SE-ResNet / 89.29 96.67 100.0 78.57 85.19 100.0 100.0 100.0 93.72 96.06 90.77 96.25