Table 1.
Study | Country | Case Samples | Controls | Baseline Mean-Age | Gender | Study type | Measure used for P. gingivalis | Measure used for AD | Follow-up | Quality Assessment |
(Noble et al., 2014) [42] | USA (Manhattan) | 110 incident AD cases | 109 without incident CI at last follow-up | Cases: 79 Controls: 72 | 67.8% Female | Case-cohort study | Serum IgG AB levels by checkboard immunoblotting | Series of neurological tests CARE- Diagnostic Interview | 5 years | 11/14 (79%) |
(Ide et al., 2016) [40] | UK (South Hampton) | 22 mild/moderate AD Patients with PD | 37 mild AD Patients w/out PD | Cases: 74.9 Controls: 79.4 | 49.2% Female | Observational cohort study for 6 months | Venous blood sample for CRP, pro-cytokine TNFα, IL10, and AB to PG. Number of teeth and full periodontal chart for presence or absence of periodontitis | NINCDS-ARDRA1 ADAS-cog2 sMMSE | 6 months | 10/14 (71%) |
(Poole et al., 2013) [10] | UK (New Castle) | 10 AD brain samples | 10 Non-AD brain samples | Cases: 80.2 Controls: 74.8 | N/A | Random case-control | Immunolabelling and immunoblotting with anti-PG | Confirmed AD brain samples | N/A3 | 7/11 (64%) |
(Sparks Stein et al., 2012) [43] | USA (University of Kentucky) | 35 developed AD. (46 developed MCI, 81 in total) | 77 cognitively intact | Cases: 74.1 (for AD) Controls: 70 | Cases: 74.3% Female Control: 58.4% Female | case-control study nested within a cohort study. | Venous blood evaluation for levels of IgG AB to the oral bacteria | NINCDS-ARDRA1 McKann et al. Criteria: MMSE | Cases: 9.6–9.8 years Controls: 12.5 years | 8/12 (67%) |
(Laugisch et al., 2018) [41] | Germany | 20 AD patients | 20 DEM-noAD5 patients | Cases: 58.3 Controls: 61.1 | Cases: 55% Female Control: 40% Female | pilot observational study | CSF by lumbar puncture Blood serum Full clinical periodontal examination Subgingival biofilm sample and gingival crevicular fluid | AD by:NIAA (2011) guideline4, MMSE CSF for biomarkers MRI CERAD | N/A1 | 8/12 (67%) |
(Kamer et al., 2009) [44] | USA (New York) | 18 AD patients | 16 cognitively normal | Cases: 40–65 (n = 2), 66–79 (n = 6), > 80 (n = 10) Controls: 40–65 (n = 7), 66–79 (n = 6),>80 | Cases: 78% Female Control: 94% Female | Longitudinal case study | Fasting plasma for IgG AB and cytokine levels APOE genotyping using frozen whole blood. | NINCDS-ARDRA1 DSM-IV MMSE | N/A3 | 8/12 (67%) |
IgG, immunoglobulin; AD, Alzheimer’s disease; TD, Treponema denticola; TF, Treponema forsythia; PG, Porphyromonas gingivalis; AB, antibody; sMMSE, standardized Mini-Mental Examination; LPS, lipopolysaccharides; MRI, magnetic resonance imaging; CSF, cerebrospinal fluid; APOE, Apolipoprotein E; CERAD, Consortium to Establish a Registry for Alzheimer’s Disease; DSM-IV, Diagnostic and Statistical Manual for Mental Diseases- 4th Edition. 1NINCDS-ADRDA National Institute of Neurological and Communicative Disorders and Stroke and the Alzheimer’s Disease and Related Disorders Association. One of the most commonly used criteria in the diagnosis of Alzheimer’s disease [70]. 2ADAS-COG, Alzheimer’s Disease Assessment Scale-cognitive subscale. 3Not Applicable or available. 4National Institutes of Health and the Alzheimer’s Association Guidelines published in 2011. It includes new revised diagnostic clinical criteria for Alzheimer’s disease. The new guidelines include a deeper understanding of the early stages of the disease [71]. 5In the study by Laugisch et al. [41], the controls used were patients diagnosed with dementing diseases other than Alzheimer’s disease.