TABLE V. Diagnosis Performance on Our Seven Tasks (%).
Task | Model | ACC | SEN | SPE | F-score | BAC |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Task 1 | 3-D-CNN | 92.40 | 96.20 | 88.60 | 92.68 | 92.40 |
3-D-VGG | 92.40 | 100 | 84.81 | 92.94 | 92.40 | |
3-D-ResNet | 87.97 | 94.93 | 81.01 | 88.75 | 87.75 | |
Multitask 3-D-GCNN | 94.30 | 100 | 88.61 | 94.61 | 94.30 | |
Task 2 | 3-D-CNN | 88.04 | 82.44 | 93.65 | 87.33 | 88.04 |
3-D-VGG | 88.78 | 85.36 | 92.19 | 88.38 | 88.78 | |
3-D-ResNet | 86.82 | 76.58 | 97.07 | 85.32 | 96.82 | |
Multitask 3-D-GCNN | 92.19 | 89.75 | 94.63 | 92.00 | 92.19 | |
Task 3 | 3-D-CNN | 93.46 | 90.76 | 96.15 | 93.28 | 93.46 |
3-D-VGG | 93.07 | 87.69 | 96.42 | 92.68 | 93.07 | |
3-D-ResNet | 93.84 | 89.23 | 98.46 | 93.54 | 93.84 | |
Multitask 3-D-GCNN | 94.23 | 90.76 | 97.69 | 94.02 | 94.23 | |
Task 4 | 3-D-CNN | 72.11 | 92.30 | 51.92 | 76.80 | 72.11 |
3-D-VGG | 67.30 | 90.76 | 43.26 | 73.64 | 67.30 | |
3-D-ResNet | 68.26 | 91.34 | 45.19 | 74.21 | 68.26 | |
Multitask 3-D-GCNN | 78.36 | 86.53 | 70.19 | 80 | 78.36 | |
Task 5 | 3-D-CNN | 85.11 | 87.64 | 82.58 | 85.47 | 85.11 |
3-D-VGG | 84.83 | 79.77 | 89.88 | 84.02 | 84.83 | |
3-D-ResNet | 83.98 | 80.89 | 87.07 | 83.47 | 83.98 | |
Multitask 3-D-GCNN | 88.48 | 82.58 | 94.38 | 87.76 | 88.48 | |
Task 6 | 3-D-CNN | 82.13 | 65.22 | 99.04 | 78.49 | 82.13 |
3-D-VGG | 83.57 | 68.34 | 98.80 | 80.62 | 83.57 | |
3-D-ResNet | 80.93 | 62.58 | 99.28 | 76.65 | 80.93 | |
Multitask 3-D-GCNN | 91.48 | 83.69 | 99.28 | 90.76 | 91.48 | |
Task 7 | 3-D-CNN | 95.40 | 91.34 | 99.46 | 95.20 | 95.39 |
3-D-VGG | 91 | 82.00 | 100 | 90.10 | 91 | |
3-D-ResNet | 94.45 | 88.90 | 100 | 94.12 | 94.44 | |
Multitask 3-D-GCNN | 96.16 | 92.60 | 99.73 | 96.02 | 96.16 |