Skip to main content
. 2020 Nov 24;8:213554–213565. doi: 10.1109/ACCESS.2020.3040198

TABLE 2. Strength and Limitation Analysis With Other Proposed Methods.

Model Major Strengths Major Limitations
Broadcast
  • No public adoption issues

  • User’s privacy is protected

  • Mostly accessible by all

  • Significant privacy risk for Covid-19 carriers

  • Data accuracy issue

  • High risk of misinformation and mass panic

Selective Broadcast
  • Moderate privacy risk for COVID-19 carriers

  • Mass panic may be limited

  • Data accuracy issue

  • Risk of misinformation

  • Limited by technological requirements

Unicast
  • Low risk of mass panic

  • Data accuracy is high

  • No privacy for the user

  • Not helpful for the mass people

Participatory
  • User’s privacy is protected from mass people

  • There can be fraudulent activity

  • Mass user adoption is low

  • Full consent is needed from the COVID-19 carrier

Private Kit: Safe Path
  • Overall accuracy is high

  • Moderate to low privacy risk for the COVID-19 carrier.

  • Limited by technological requirements

  • Full consent is required from the COVID-19 carrier

Proposed Solution
  • High accuracy of location data

  • Users’ cell phones must not be smartphones rather any phone with an active sim card.

  • To collect the data, no user application is needed

  • Less false negative issue

  • The user has to carry the cell phone