Skip to main content
. 2020 Dec 7;8:220227–220245. doi: 10.1109/ACCESS.2020.3043174

TABLE 12. Statistical Comparison Between Meta-Heuristics for CEC2015 Problems.

IPA vs. Sum of Ranks Inline graphic-val. Inline graphic-val. Sign.
W+ W−
SOA 8 37 1.65632 0.04882 IPA
SHO 0 45 2.88563 0.00195 IPA
GWO 0 45 2.88563 0.00195 IPA
PSO 17 28 0.56759 0.28515 –
MFO 8 37 1.65632 0.04882 IPA
MVO 17 28 0.56759 0.28515 –
SCA 0 45 2.88563 0.00195 IPA
GSA 6 39 1.92135 0.02734 IPA
GA 0 45 2.88563 0.00195 IPA
DE 7 38 1.78526 0.03710 IPA