Table 1.
Systemic review of the included studies in meta-analysis.
| Author | Country | Study design | Male infertility Definition | Characteristics of men with infertility | Characteristics of men without infertility | Follow-up period | Control of confounder variables | Outcome of interest | Main findings |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Eisenberg et al. (19) | USA | Retrospective Cohort |
Men with azoospermia | N = 451 Age = 35.5 (8.3) BMI = NM |
N = 1787 Age = 35.8 (6.9) BMI = NM |
6.7 years | Adjusted for age and year of evaluation | All cancers | Compared to the general population, men with infertility had a higher risk of cancer. Stratifying by the azoospermia status showed that azoospermic men had an elevated risk of cancer, and those without azoospermia had a trend toward a higher rate of cancer |
| Eisenberg et al. (20) | USA | Retrospective Cohort |
ICD-9 | N = 76083 Age = 35.08 (5.89) BMI = NM |
N = 760830 Age = NM BMI = NM |
277703 person-years | Matched on age and follow-up time | All and individual cancers of testicular, prostate, melanoma, kidney, upper aerodigestive, stomach, colon and rectum, liver and gallbladder, pancreas, urinary bladder, breast and lung, esophagus, leukemia, Hodgkin lymphoma, non-Hodgkin lymphoma, thyroid, nervous system |
Men with infertility had a higher risk of testicular cancer, non-Hodgkin lymphoma and all cancers than the counterparts men without infertility |
| Elenkov et al. (11) | Sweden | Prospective population-based cohort | Being childless | N = 2134 Age = 48.9 (4.1) BMI = 25.3 (3.8) |
N = 9209 Age = 48.7 (3.9) BMI = 25 (3.2) |
Up to 42 years | Adjusted for smoking, education and marital status, BMI, high blood pressure | Prostate cancer | Childless men had the higher risk of prostate cancer-related mortality compared to men with children. However, the prostate cancer incidence did not differ between them |
| Hanson et al. (21) | USA | Retrospective cohort |
All men presenting for infertility that underwent semen analysis | N = 20433 Age = NM BMI = NM |
N = 20433 Age = NM BMI = NM |
On average for 7.3 years with a maximum of 18 years | Matched on age and birth year | All cancers, and prostate, testicular, melanoma, and other cancers | Men with semen analysis had an increased risk of testicular cancer compared to men without infertility. There were no significant differences in the cancer risk for the other common sites or the overall risk of cancer |
| Walsh et al. (22) | USA | Retrospective cohort |
Infertile men with abnormal semen WHO-1999 criteria | N = 4549 Age = 38.1 (7.4) BMI = NM |
N = 14557 Age = 36.4 (6.4) BMI = NM |
Mean (SD): 11.4 (2.9) years | Matched on age | Testicular Cancer | Men with infertility had an increased risk of subsequently developing testicular cancer |
| Walsh et al. (23) | USA | Retrospective cohort |
Infertile men with abnormal semen WHO-1999 criteria | N = 4549 Age = 38.1 (7.4) BMI = NM |
N = 14557 Age = 36.4 (6.4) BMI = NM |
Mean (SD): 11.4 (2.9) years | Matched on age and geography | Prostate Cancer | Men with male infertility were found to have an increased risk of subsequently developing high-grade prostate cancer |
| Jacobsen et al. (24) | Denmark | Retrospective cohort |
All men in couples with fertility problems who had impaired semen analysis | N = 29177 Age = NM BMI = NM |
N = 300000 Age = NM BMI = NM |
NM | NM | All cancers, and testicular, peritoneum and other cancers | Men with infertility were more likely to develop testicular and peritoneum and other digestive organs cancer than other men |
| Al-Jebari et al. (25) | Sweden | Retrospective cohort |
All men used assisted reproductive techniques including IVF and ICSI | N = 35500 Age = NM BMI = NM |
N = 1145990 Age = NM BMI = NM |
14389198 person years |
Adjusted for fathers’ age at childbirth, father’s education level | Prostate cancer | Men who became fathers through assisted reproduction had a statistically significantly increased risk of prostate cancer compared with men who conceived naturally |
ICD, International Statistical Classification of Diseases; 9th edition; BMI, Body Mass Index; IVF, In vitro fertilization; ICSI, Intracytoplasmic sperm injection; NM, Not mentioned.