Table 4.
|
RYGB
|
LSG
|
Comments
|
Type of procedure | Combined malabsorptive and restrictive | Restrictive | |
Effect on weight loss | +++ | +++ | Most studies demonstrate comparable weight loss, with slight superiority of RYGB shown in some reports |
Remission of diabetes | +++ | ++ | RYGB superior to LSG |
Short term glycemic improvement | +++ | ++ | RYGB superior to LSG |
Long term glycemic improvement | +++ | ++ | RYGB superior to LSG |
Improvement in hypertension | ++ | + | RYGB superior to LSG |
Improvement in dyslipidemia | ++ | + | RYGB superior to LSG |
Improvement in gastroesophageal reflux disease | ++ | + | RYGB superior to LSG |
Postoperative complications | + | +/- | Postoperative complication and reoperation rates less with LSG than RYGB |
Long-term nutritional deficiencies | ++ | + | LSG safer that RYGB |
LSG: Laparoscopic sleeve gastrectomy; RYGB: Laparoscopic Roux-en-Y gastric bypass.