Skip to main content
. 2021 Oct 29;2021(10):CD013658. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD013658.pub2

Mansell 2017.

Study characteristics
Methods Retrospective multi‐centre cohort
June 2009 to August 2012
Glasgow Breast Units (Victoria & Western Infirmary), UK
1010 patients
Participants Inclusion: Women with breast cancer undergoing breast‐conserving surgery or mastectomy and reconstruction
Exclusion: Patients with previous DCIS or breast cancer were excluded
Interventions Intervention:
Volume displacement and volume replacement (analysed together), (n = 104)
VD: (n = 90);
Wise pattern reduction (78), Benelli‐type “roundblock” (6), "Racquettype” excision (3), Lejour (1), Grisotti (1) and “melon slice” reduction (1)
VR: (n=14);
Thoracoepigastric flap (9), breast matrix rotation (4) and thoracodorsal artery perforator (TDAP) flap (1)
Control:
(1) WLE (2) Mastectomy with and without reconstruction
Outcomes Primaryoutcomes (median: (I) 56.8 months (C) 57.2 months/54.4 months
  • Local recurrence

  • Disease free survival

  • Overall survival


Secondaryoutcomes:

Otheroutcomes:
  • Distant recurrence

  • Margins

Notes Different outcomes to Mansell 2015
No disclosures/funding declared