Table 4. Effectiveness results of management-based mobile interventions.
Management-based mobile interventions | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Outcome and outcome domain | Study ID | Effect estimate [95% CI or p value] | Statistical significance | Clinical importance | GRADE certainty |
Antenatal interventions | |||||
Biological stress | Dennis-Tiwary 2017 [64] | F 1,22 = 4.96 [p = 0.037] | Yes | No | Low |
Utilization of care | Hantsoo 2018 [65] | MD = 0.88 [-1.08 to 2.84] | No | No | Very low |
Perinatal interventions | |||||
Psychological wellbeing | Carissoli 2017 [62] | Autonomy F = 5.725 [p<0.05] | Yes | No | Very low |
Postpartum interventions | |||||
Depression severity | Prasad 2018 [67] Sawyer 2019 [68] |
MD = -0.93 [-2.08 to 0.21] | No | No | Very low |
Depression severity | Baumel 2018 [61] | MD = 2.82 [-0.49 to 6.13] | No | No | Low |
Depression severity | Jannati 2020 [66] | MD = -6.87 [-7.92 to -5.82] | Yes | Yes | Very low |
Anxiety severity | Constant 2014 [63] | MD = -1.30 [-2.33 to -0.27] | Yes | No | Very low |
Psychological wellbeing | Prasad 2018 [67] | MD = 0.23 [-2.73 to 0.73] | Yes | No | Very low |
Psychological stress | Constant 2014 [63] | Avoidance B = -1.8 [-3.2 to -0.4] Intrusion B = -1.4 [-2.9 to 0.2] |
Yes No |
No No |
Very low |
Utilization of care | Sawyer 2019 [68] | [intervention vs control; p value] GP visits: 78% vs 63% [p = 0.09] A&E visits: 15% vs 4% [p = 0.04] Online care: 67% vs 46% [p = 0.03] |
No Yes Yes |
No No No |
Very low |