Table 1.
Characteristics of 9 RCTs included in the meta-analysis.
Intervention | ||||||||||
Studies | Sample size (T/C) | Mean age, y (SD) | Design | Diagnostic criteria for insomnia | Diagnostic criteria for anxiety | Treatment | Control | Duration of intervention, wk | Adverse events | Outcome measures |
Deng, 2017[42] | 50/45 | T: 41.66 (3.12)C: 43.0 (6.15) | 2 Parallel arms | CCMD-3, GDTCIDCM | CCMD-3, GDTCIDCM | Modified XYS(1 dose/400 mL/day) | Mirtazapine Tablets(30 mg, qd) | 8 | Y | CEIT, HAMA, PSQI |
Li, 2016[59] | 40/40 | T: 42.39 (5.17)C: 42.45 (5.26) | 2 parallel arms | CCMD-3, CDTEDSTCM, GCRNCM | CCMD-3, CDTEDSTCM, GCRNCM | Modified XYS(2 mg, tid) + C | Estazolam tablets(1 mg, qd) | 6 | Y | CEIT, SSSI, SAS |
Chen and Zhou2019[54] | 26/26 | T: 44.04 (10.94)C: 46.50 (12.50) | 2 Parallel arms | CCMD-3, CDTEDSTCM, GDTCIDCM | CCMD-3, CDTEDSTCM, GDTCIDCM | Modified XYS(4 dose/day) + C | Mirtazapine Tablets(30 mg, qd) | 2 | Y | CEIT, AEs, PSQI, SSSI |
Huang and Xiang, 2014[52] | 34/28 | T: 43.5 (2.5)C: 41.5 (2.5) | 2 Parallel arms | CCMD-3 | CCMD-3 | Modified XYS(1 dose/day) | Estazolam tablets(1 mg, qd) | 4 | N | CEIT, SAS |
Hou, 2014[55] | 30/30 | T: 39 (12.55)C: 42 (11.76) | 2 Parallel arms | CCMD-3, CDTEDSTCM, PSQI | CCMD-3, CDTEDSTCM, HAMA | Modified XYS(1 dose/day) + C | Estazolam tablets(1 mg, qd) | 4 | Y | CEIT, CEAT, CEAH, CEIP, HAMA, PSQI, SSSI, SSSA, TESS |
Li, 2019[56] | 30/30 | T: 39.93 (10.27)C: 41.03 (10.31) | 2 Parallel arms | CCMD-3, CDTEDSTCM | CCMD-3, CDTEDSTCM | Modified XYS(1 dose/day) + C | Zopiclone tablets(7.5 mg, qd) | 4 | N | CEAH, CEIP, HAMA, PSQI, SSSI, SSSA |
Xue and Guo, 2009[53] | 44/43 | 21-68 | 2 parallel arms | CCMD-3, PSQI | CCMD-3, HAMA | Modified XYS(1 dose/day) | Mirtazapine Tablets(10–45 mg, qd) | 5 | Y | PSQI, HAMA |
Tang, 2018[57] | 40/40 | T: 44.7 (4.1)C: 45.9 (3.2) | 2 parallel arms | CCMD-3, PSQI | CCMD-3, HAMA | Modified XYS(1 dose/day) + C | Eszopiclone tablets (2 mg, qd) + ZAC (1.8 g, qd) | 15 | N | PSQI, SAS |
Liu, 2017[49] | 53/52 | T: 26.8 (5.5)C: 43.5 (5.6) | 2 parallel arms | CCMD-3, PSQI | CCMD-3, SAS | Modified XYS(1 dose/day) + C | Estazolam tablets(1 mg, qd) | 6 | N | PSQI, SAS |