Table 2.
Method | Strengths | Limitations | Applications | Metric | Dynamic range | Sensitivitya |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
SYBR-based qPCR | Sensitivity Broad target compatibility Detection reproducibility Common standard operating procedure Cheaper than probe-based technologies |
Multi-step workflows Commonly requires purified RNA Input required for many miRNA screenings can be too high for scarce samples Non-specific amplification difficult to measure IsomiR sequences difficult to discriminate |
Discovery development, Validation, Safety assessment/Preclinical studies, Clinical | Cycle threshold (Ct) | 7 logs | ++++ |
Hydrolysis probe-based (“TaqMan”) qPCR | Sensitivity Broad target compatibility Detection reproducibility Specificity vs. SYBR qPCR Common standard operating procedure |
Multi-step workflows Commonly requires purified RNA Input required for many miRNA screenings can be too high for scarce samples Non-specific amplification difficult to measure IsomiR sequences difficult to discriminate |
Discovery and development, Validation, Safety assessment/Preclinical studies, Clinical | Cycle threshold (Ct) | 7 logs | ++++ |
Digital PCR | Digital quantification without standard curve Sensitivity due to end-point amplification |
Multi-step workflows Commonly requires purified RNA Non-specific amplification difficult to measure IsomiR sequences difficult to discriminate |
Discovery and development, Validation, Safety assessment/Preclinical studies, Clinical | Copy number | 5 logs | ++++ |
Bead hybridization | Can be compatible with biofluids and tissues without RNA purification Low input with amplification |
Number of miRNA detected Sensitivity without amplification is poor IsomiR sequences difficult to discriminate |
Discovery, Validation, Safety assessment/Preclinical studies, Clinical | Abundance (with curve) | 5 logs | ++++ |
Next generation sequencing | Breadth of small RNA species detected Single nucleotide specificity Can distinguish isomiRs |
Laborious multi-step workflow Input for workflows too high for scarce samples |
Discovery and development | Reads per unit | 5–6 logs | ++ |
Digital counting | Lack of amplification bias Digital quantification without standard curve |
Input requirements higher than qPCR Generally lower specificity within miRNA families IsomiR sequences difficult to discriminate |
Discovery and development, Validation, Safety assessment/Preclinical studies, Clinical | Counts | 5–6 logs | ++ |
Microarray | Breadth of miRNA detected | Workflows are labor intensive Input for workflows is high, requires purified RNA Generally lower specificity within miRNA families IsomiR sequences difficult to discriminate |
Discovery and development | Relative fluorescence | 3–4 logs | + |
Abbreviations: miRNA, microRNA; qPCR, quantitative PCR.
Sources: Jensen et al. (2011), Sah et al. (2010), Tan et al. (2015), and Godoy et al. (2019).
++++ = <100 copies, +++ = 100–1000 copies, ++ = 1000–5000 copies, and + = ≥5001 copies.