Table 8.
Control measures to prevent exposure to animal feces in LMIC.
| Category | Major pathway | Targeted arrow | Intervention | Major findings | References |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Animal waste management | Waterborne/ environmental |
Animal feces –> fluids, fields | Biogas digesters | A low-cost plastic type digester in Cameroon considerably decreased the mean counts of coliform and E. coli in the slurries of chicken feces to 138 and 87 CFU/mL, respectively, after a five-week retention time in the digester | (247) |
| The concentration of Enterococcus spp., E. coli and spores of Cl. Perfringens in pig slurries was reduced by 1–2 log CFU/mL after the treatment of biogas digesters in Vietnamese pig farms | (248) | ||||
| Biogas digesters with various designs can reduce the concentration of Enterococci, E. coli, and coliforms by 1 ~ 3.5 log10 CFU/mL in the manure | (249) | ||||
| Composting | The concentration of E. coli was reduced from 4 log10 CFU/g to below the detection limit in composted pig manure added 2% urea within 2 weeks. The counts of total coliforms decreased to 0.72 log10 CFU/g at day 45 | (250) | |||
| Corralling domestic small animal | Animal contact | Animal feces –> fingers | Corralling free-range chicken | Corralling didn't fully achieve the goal of separating children from poultry as children in the household persistently played with corrals and with chickens in the corrals | (251) |
| A significant higher (two-fold) incidence of Campylobacter-related diarrhea in children living in the corral group than in the control group | (252) | ||||
| The participant households in the corral group were revisited 10 years after the intervention, and majority of them (92.3%) had a positive change in their attitudes toward corral use | (253) | ||||
| Hutching small animals inside home | Participants reported that the three-level animal hatches constructed in kitchen and living space prevented rabbits and guinea pigs from defecating throughout the house which thus prevented children from eating animal feces on the floor | (254) | |||
| Baby WaSH | Animal contact/ environmental |
Animal feces –> fingers, fields –> future victim | Provision of play-yard/play pen | The WaSH intervention package including providing plastic manufactured play-yards showed non-statistically significant effects on reducing both enteric infections and pathogen-attributable diarrhea caused by individual pathogens | (36, 255) |
| The community-built play-yards (play-yards made from local materials) protected the young children from ingesting soil and livestock feces | (256) | ||||
| Provision of plastic playmats | Locally sourced plastic playmats were provided to caregivers in a pilot study, and they reported that use of playmats reduced the mouthing of dirt by children | (254) | |||
| Milk hygiene | Foodborne | Animal feces –> food, food –> future victim | Boiling or heating raw milk | The application of pasteurization in raw milk can cause the pathogen's probability of surviving to be reduced by a factor of 106, and, consequently, destroy all vegetative microbes in the milk | (257, 258) |
| Natural fermentation | The reduced pH along with the release of antimicrobial compounds by fermenting bacteria synergistically inhibit the growth of pathogenic microbes in the milk | (257) | |||
| Smoking the inner surface of milk-handling containers | The mean microbial load in the smoked containers was reduced from 5.99 to 4.64 log10 cfu/cm2 for total viable count (TVC), from 5.07 to 4.00 log10 cfu/cm2 for total coliform count (TCC), and from 4.81 to 3.75 log10 cfu/cm2 for LAB | (259) | |||
| The qualitative study conducted in Ethiopia identified the smoking of milk-handling containers as one of potential risk mitigation practices in the pastoral communities | (260) | ||||
| Complementary food hygiene | Foodborne | Animal feces –> food, animal feces –> fomites, fomites –> food, fingers –> food, fomites –> future victim | Cleaning and disinfecting baby feeding bottles | Rinsing baby bottles with soapy water followed by tap water can reduce the load of fecal bacteria including EPEC and Salmonella spp. by 3.1 ~ 3.7 log10 CFU/mL | (261) |
| The trial of improved practices showed that caregivers preferred the protocol of brushing the bottle with dish detergent for 30 s after every use than boiling the bottle for several minutes daily | (262) | ||||
| Intervention package of critical food hygiene behaviors | Six critical behaviors were identified and targeted: (1) handwashing before cooking; (2) handwashing before feeding; (3) washing cooking utensils with safe water and soap and drying them on a clean and elevated surface; (4) proper and safe storage of cooked food and utensils; (5) reheating food before feeding; (6) boiling drinking water. The results suggested a varying degree of increase in targeted complementary food hygiene behaviors | (263–269) | |||
| Food samples collected 3 weeks after mother taking the training showed a significant reduction in the thermotolerant coliform (TTC) contamination levels which were reduced below 10 TTC/g for most samples cooled after cooking or reheated after storage | (270, 271) | ||||
| Besides the increased adoption rate of improved behaviors, children's reported diarrhea was reduced by 60 and 30% at 6 and 32 months post-intervention, respectively | (272) | ||||
| Handwashing | Foodborne | Fingers –> food, fingers –> future victim | Handwashing at critical time points | Promotions of handwashing after defecation or after disposal of children's feces and before eating, preparing, or handling foods prevent around 25% of diarrhea episodes in LMIC settings | (273) |
| Improvement of water quality | Waterborne | Fluids –> food, fluids –> future victim | Source-based and point-of-use water improvements | Distributing disinfection products (chlorine products, flocculation and disinfection sachets) to households may reduce diarrhea by around 25% (RR 0.77, 95% CI 0.65–0.91 for chlorine products; RR 0.69, 95% CI 0.58–0.82 for flocculation and disinfection sachets). POU filtration systems may lower diarrhea episodes by around a half (RR: 0.48; 95% CI: 0.38–0.59). Proper application of solar disinfection may reduce diarrhea by around 30% (RR: 0.62; 95% CI: 0.42–0.94) | (274) |