Skip to main content
. 2021 Nov 1;15(11):e0009239. doi: 10.1371/journal.pntd.0009239

Table 4. The ethical assessment of the included nudge strategies targeting health promotion behaviors related to neglected tropical diseases in low- and middle-income countries.

Studies Nudges Reflective preferences Health benefits Low-processing motivation Democratic legitimation Easy resistibility Long-run autonomy Available alternatives Trust relationship
Amin et al., 2019 1. Simplification L H M L H H L H
Biran el a., 2014 1. Public pledges M H M H M M M H
2. Posters role-model M H M H H H M H
3. Prompts of pro-social behavior M H M H M L M H
4. Reminders in bathroom M H M H H H M H
5. HWWS village certificates M H M H M L M H
Biran et al., 2020 1. Public pledges M H H H M M L H
2. Stickers as signals M H H H M L L H
Biswas et al., 2017 1. Reminder sticker M H M M H H M H
Burns et al., 2018 1. Hope soap L H H L M M H H
Buttenheim et al., 2018 1. Advanced Planning H L L H H H L H
2. Reminder planning H L L H H H L H
3. Block Leader Recruitment H L L H H H L H
4. Contingent Group Lotteries H L L H M M L H
Caruso et al., 2019 1. Transect walk with colors M M M H H M M H
2. Banners and mural—signaling M M M H M L M H
3. Self-Commitment and poster M M M H H H M H
Chidziwisano et al., 2019/2020 1. Public pledges M H M M M M M H
2. Stickers as signals M H M M M L M H
Contzen et al., 2015 1. Public-commitment M H M M M M L M
Friederich et al., 2020 1. Public pledge M M M M M M M H
2. Photo as signal M M M M M L M H
3. Stickers as reminders M M M M H H M H
Gauri, et al 2018 1. Norm entrepreneurs M M M H H H M L
Gautam et al., 2017 1. Public pledges M H M H M M M M
2. Competitions M H M H M L M M
3. Reminders in kitchen M H M H H H M M
4. Role-model pictures M H M H H H M M
5. Signaling safe food zones M H M H M L M M
Grover et al., 2018 1. Contextual painted cues L H H M H H L H
Haung et al., 2020 1. Contextual painted cues L H H H H H H H
2. Posters simplifying info L H H H H H H H
3. Eyes sticker L H H H H H H H
4. Arrow sticker L H H H H H H H
Haushofer et al., 2019 1. Visualization L H M L H H H H
2. Planning L H M L H H H H
Inauen et al., 2019 1. Planning reminders M H H L H H M L
2. Public Commitment M H H L M M M L
Jetha et al., 2019 1. Public Pledge M H H H M M M H
Karing et al., 2018 1. Social signaling H H L H M L H H

Note. H = high ethical standard; M = moderate ethical standard; L = low ethical standard