Table 2.
Error rates and characteristics of TCN and comparison models.
Method | # params | L-M | L-H | VT-H | MAX | Combined | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Random forest21 | 298,106 | 20 ± 134 | 144 ± 187 | 54 ± 169 | 15 ± 111 | 62 ± 164 | 134 ± 151 | |||
SLSTM23 | 21,589 | 93 ± 133 | 52 ± 145 | −58 ± 148 | −16 ± 178 | 21 ± 160 | −48 ± 243 | |||
SLSTM + {HRR,} | 21,845 | 52 ± 132 | 7 ± 163 | −72 ± 152 | −37 ± 163 | −10 ± 159 | −17 ± 205 |
Filters | Receptive field (s) | Validation loss | ||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
TCN-VO2 A | 24 | 218 | 0.02506 | 19,921 | −23 ± 116 | 14 ± 136 | −49 ± 115 | −32 ± 117 | −22 ± 122 | 18 ± 182 |
TCN-VO2 B | 16 | 187 | 0.02525 | 8081 | −7 ± 109 | 30 ± 138 | −25 ± 115 | −2 ± 113 | −1 ± 120 | 62 ± 162 |
TCN-VO2 C | 16 | 76 | 0.02585 | 5393 | −21 ± 113 | 16 ± 159 | −57 ± 136 | 3 ± 123 | −17 ± 137 | 93 ± 214 |
TCN-VO2 D | 16 | 91 | 0.02586 | 6241 | −24 ± 115 | 31 ± 142 | −54 ± 123 | 9 ± 117 | −11 ± 128 | 80 ± 165 |
TCN-VO2 NH | 24 | 1 | 0.04895 | 361 | 10 ± 127 | 133 ± 179 | 69 ± 129 | 75 ± 123 | 72 ± 149 | 223 ± 196 |
TCN-VO2 A(HR) | 24 | 218 | 0.10733 | 19,057 | 197 ± 286 | 133 ± 373 | 40 ± 412 | 145 ± 445 | 127 ± 379 | −220 ± 445 |
Errors are reported as mean ± SD [ml min−1].
SLSTM stacked long short-term memory.