Skip to main content
. 2021 Nov 5;21(21):7361. doi: 10.3390/s21217361

Table 1.

Studies related to attitude determination (simulation and in-orbit observations).

Reference Method (Instruments) Goal Results/Remarks
[4] Simulation Attitude determination (AD) based solely on magnetometer Converges from initial attitude errors of maximum 60° and with an attitude accuracy of 1° (1σ) or better
[5] Observation (Rossi X-ray Timing Explorer satellite calibration maneuvers, Terra and Wide-Field Infrared Explorer mission, Upper Atmosphere Research Satellite (UARS)) On-orbit calibration of satellite gyroscopes Methods comparison (attitude accuracy below 1°). The Delta-bias algorithm gives slightly less accurate results than the Davenport and BICal algorithms
[6] Simulation Absolute alignment calibration of a system comprising two star trackers, an inertial sensor assembly (ISA) of three fiber-optic gyros, and an imaging instrument based on Alignment Kalman Filter (AKF) AKF is effective to estimate absolute misalignments and gyro calibration parameters
[7] Simulation AD using an Extended Kalman Filter (EKF), which applies the albedo model with a magnetometer and sun sensor Attitude accuracy below 1°
[8] Simulation and Observation (Total Ozone Mapping Spectrometer (TOMS)) Modeling the albedo for Sun/Earth sensor used in attitude determination Albedo compensation in attitude estimation, improves the maximum error from 9.9° to 1.9°
[9] Simulation AD using Unscented Kalman Filter (UKF) based only on magnetometer The attitude estimation accuracies are below 0.5° after convergence
[10] Simulation (PROBA-2 Spacecraft scenarios) Navigation system for magnetic-only orbit and attitude estimation using the square-root Unscented filter (MAGSURF) RSS attitude error of less than 1.4° and a time of convergence of less than 2 orbits
[11] Simulation Attitude and rate estimation algorithm using EKF based only on geomagnetic field data Filter converges within the +/−8° range for any initial attitude error
[12] Simulation (Radio Aurora Explorer satellites (3U CubeSat)) AD based on gyros, magnetometers, coarse sun sensors, and an EKF In the sun, the angular uncertainty is between 2° and 3°, and in eclipse, the uncertainty increases to between 7° and 8°
[13] Simulation AD using two-step EKF based on a magnetometer only Attitude accuracies of less than 1°
[3] Observation (Radio Aurora Explorer satellites (3U CubeSat)) Photodiodes calibration and AD from EKF/UKF with albedo model based on the calibrated photodiodes, three-axis magnetometer and gyrometer Angular improvement of 10° in sun vector from the photodiodes, and below 1° accuracy on the attitude determination
[14] Simulation AD via a robust Adaptive Kalman Filter based on magnetometer and gyro measurement Precision of traditional EKF is about 0.2°, and the maximum estimate error of the robust adaptive filter is 0.1°
[15] Simulation and Observation (experimental data with on-ground nano-satellite) Gain-scheduled EKF (GSEKF) to reduce the computational requirement in the nanosatellite attitude determination process Attitude accuracy below 0.2° during the entire orbital period. Computation time could be reduced by 86.29% and 89.45%
[16] Simulation Magnetometer calibration with Hyper least square (HyperLS) estimator for ellipsoid fitting, then utilized for attitude determination via non-linear colored noise filters of EKF, simplex UKF and cubature Kalman filter Attitude accuracy below 1° for simplex UKF
[17] Observation (images taken from International Space Station (ISS)) AD utilizing color earth images taken with visible light camera Attitude accuracy is about few degrees or less
[18] Simulation Heat attitude model for satellite attitude determination Attitude accuracy between 0.2 ° to 5°
[19] Simulation AD method based on an UKF, using a gyrometer, a magnetometer and solar panels as a sun sensor The UKF has shown precision in Euler angles of about 1.1°, which is better than for EKF. UKF has a considerably longer processing time compared to EKF
[20] Simulation and Observation (experimentation on-ground set up) Thermal imaging sensors to determine attitude of the Sun and the horizon by employing a homogeneous array of such detectors Angular accuracy below 1°