Skip to main content
. 2021 Nov 9;10(13):9. doi: 10.1167/tvst.10.13.9

Table 3.

Comparison of Segmentation of Layer Boundary Lines by the CNN Models to Human Graders

Central 6 mm of B-Scan, Pixels Full B-Scan Width (9 mm), Pixels
Bland–Altman Analysis Mean Difference SE CoR (1.96 * SD) Mean Difference SE CoR (1.96 * SD)
U-Net vs. graders ILM 0.311 0.012 8.107 0.499 0.013 9.827
dINL −0.020 0.010 6.545 −0.161 0.008 6.184
EZ −0.130 0.006 2.891 −0.131 0.006 2.870
pRPE 0.433 0.003 2.058 0.444 0.003 2.150
BM 0.372 0.003 1.786 0.343 0.003 1.937
SW vs. graders ILM 0.102 0.003 2.241 0.136 0.006 4.777
dINL −0.378 0.010 6.720 −0.451 0.008 6.146
EZ −0.578 0.007 3.327 −0.599 0.007 3.333
pRPE 0.369 0.003 1.938 0.365 0.003 1.948
BM 0.226 0.003 1.721 0.278 0.003 2.591
Hybrid model vs. graders ILM 0.135 0.003 1.663 0.146 0.003 2.260
dINL 0.030 0.009 6.168 −0.096 0.008 5.763
EZ −0.143 0.006 2.629 −0.152 0.006 2.631
pRPE 0.451 0.003 1.881 0.469 0.003 1.954
BM 0.392 0.002 1.611 0.374 0.002 1.748
Grader 2 vs. grader 1 ILM −0.021 0.002 1.106 −0.019 0.002 1.300
dINL −0.427 0.010 6.266 −0.379 0.008 5.746
EZ 0.213 0.006 2.861 0.201 0.006 2.896
pRPE −0.769 0.004 2.476 −0.747 0.003 2.491
BM −0.408 0.003 1.992 −0.389 0.003 2.052