Table 2.
Source of error | Description | Impact on data | |
Patient | Failure to follow information disclosed on patient information leaflet | All patients should be given a patient information leaflet and/or advice on what to avoid prior to performing an exercise test. | Various implications, specifically limiting exercise tolerance and impairing gas exchange data |
Poor effort/cooperation/motivation to perform exercise test | Patients need to understand the reason why the test is being performed. Failure to do so may result in suboptimal effort. | Underestimation of all indices, including workload, AT, VO2 and VCO2. | |
Test operator | Failure to give standardised instruction and encouragement during exercise | Throughout the different phases of exercise, there should be clear and standardised instructions to patients. | Various implications, specifically lack of consistency in data across different test operators |
Failure to select correct load (watts) in view of patient’s activity level/fitness | Incremental workloads that result in exercise duration of <8 or >12 min do not accurately reflect aerobic status. | Various implications, although more commonly underestimation of gas exchange indices | |
Lack awareness/guidance on the use of well-defined end of test criteria | Exercise may be stopped too early or too late in what should be a symptom limited exercise test. | If exercise is stopped early (eg, pulse rate), gas exchange indices can be underestimated. | |
Incorrect determination/identification of the AT | There should be a clear definition of what AT is and processes in place to promote discussion and review agreement. | Inappropriate estimation of level of fitness or degree of impairment in O2 delivery/use | |
Incorrect determination/measurement of slopes (ΔVE/ΔVCO2, OUES and ΔVO2/ΔWR) | The determination of slopes based on linear regression models require correct identification of the start and end points. | Incorrect inferences from data (VE/VCO2 mismatch, cardiovascular impairment, among others) | |
Equipment | Inaccurate output of power by treadmill/ergometer | Treadmill (speed/grade) and ergometer (resistance) power outputs require yearly servicing (more often if regularly moved). | Various implications, particularly overestimation or underestimation of gas exchange indices |
Non-calibrated weighing scales and stadiometer | Weighing scales and stadiometers require regular servicing and calibration if there is a suspicion of erroneous measurements. | Incorrect estimation of predicted data and consequent inaccurate inferences from recorded data | |
Excessive condensation at the point of gas analysis | Gas analysis should meet BTPS conditions, particularly humidity/water vapour pressure. | Various implications, although more commonly underestimation of gas exchange indices | |
Volume drift | Thermal or offset volume drift may occur as a result of large fluctuations in temperature or incorrect calibration | Various implications, particularly inaccurate ventilatory and gas exchange indices | |
Delayed response time and transit time in gas exchange parameters | Under certain testing conditions, there may be delay from the point of sampling to the point of gas analysis. | Normally, underestimation of gas exchange data due to dispersion of expired gases | |
High/low sampling rates/delta time/data averaging of gas exchange data | Data averaging below 30 or above 60 s will affect validity of gas exchange measurements. | Either high fluctuations or excessive attenuation in gas exchange data |
AT, anaerobic threshold; BTPS, body temperature and pressure saturated; CPET, cardiopulmonary exercise testing; OUES, oxygen uptake efficiency slope; VE/VCO2, ventilatory equivalent for carbon dioxide production; ΔVE/ΔVCO2, slope of the ventilatory response; ΔVO2/ΔWR, slope of the metabolic response.