Skip to main content
. 2021 Nov 19;100(46):e27869. doi: 10.1097/MD.0000000000027869

Table 1.

Characteristics of the included studies.

Author Year Country Age Sample (Case/control) Specimen Dysregulated status Cutoff value TP FP FN TN QUADAS-2
Abd-El-Fattah et al[19] 2013 Egypt Adult 29/37 Serum Up Unclear 28 14 1 23 7
Cai et al[24] 2016 China Child 30/30 Serum Up 1.20 26 3 4 27 5
Cao et al[25] 2014 China Child 40/60 Serum Up 0.71 32 6 8 54 5
Chen et al[26] 2020 China Adult 68/32 Sputum Up Unclear 64 2 4 30 6
Chen et al[27] 2017 China Adult 100/45 Serum Down 0.36 81 13 19 32 5
Kathirvel et al[16] 2020 India Child 30/30 Serum Up 0.70 28 1 2 29 7
Ndzi et al[20] 2019 Cameroon Adult 83/42 Serum Up Unclear 66 21 17 21 6
Shi et al[28] 2019 China Adult 72/45 Serum Down Unclear 30 7 42 38 7
Wagh et al[21] 2017 India Adult 30/30 Serum Down Unclear 29 3 1 27 6
Wu et al[22] 2012 China Adult 21/19 Serum Up Unclear 10 1 11 18 7
Zhou et al[23] 2016 China Child 68/32 Serum Up Unclear 24 3 1 18 7
Ying et al[29] 2020 China Adult 68/122 Sputum Up Unclear 64 15 4 107 7

FN = false-negative, FP = false-positive, QUADAS-2 = quality assessment of diagnostic accuracy studies-2, TN = true-negative, TP = true-positive.