Skip to main content
. 2021 Nov 18;16(11):e0256951. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0256951

Table 3. Magnitude of disrespect and abuse by verification criteria during facility-based childbirth in Borena District, South Wollo, Amhara region, Ethiopia, 2020 (n = 369).

Category and type of disrespect and abuse during labor or delivery Experience
Physical abuse YES % NO%
Health provider physically hit or slapped, pinched /pushed mother 83 (22.5) 286 (77.5)
Health provider verbally insulted mother 148 (40.1) 221 (59.9)
Mother restricted from drinking any fluid unless medically necessitated 46 (12.5) 323 (87.5)
Birth attendant(s) pushed tummy down to deliver the baby (used fundal pressure) 95 (25.7) 274 (74.3)
Birth attendant(s) allowed mother to move around (ambulate) during the course of the labor 143 (38.8) 226 (61.2)
Non-confidential care
Health providers used curtains or other physical barriers to maintain privacy 103 (27.9) 266 (72.1)
Health providers discussed mother’s private health information such that others could hear it 57 (15.4) 312 (84.6)
Person(s) other than the care providers were allowed into the birthing room who could observe mother while naked on the bed 74 (20.1) 295 (79.9)
Non-consented care
rovider did not introduce themselves or greet mother 207 (56.1) 162 (43.9)
providers did not encourage the mother and her companion to ask questions 196 (53.1) 173 (46.9)
provider did not respond to mother’s question with politeness 180 (48.8) 189 (51.2)
provider did explain what was being done and what to expect during care 176 (47.7) 193 (52.3)
Health care provider did not obtain consent or permission before a procedure 178 (48.2) 191 (51.8)
Non-dignified care
Health care providers shouted at or scolded mother 146 (39.6) 223 (60.4)
Care provider blamed mother for getting pregnant or for shouting due to the pain of labor 101 (27.4) 268 (72.6)
care providers allowed mother’s companion into delivery room 189 (51.2) 180 (48.8)
Discrimination
Health care providers discriminated by age, ethnicity, religion, and/or being rural 23 (6.2) 346 (93.8)
Health care providers discriminated against mother because of HIV+ status 14 (3.8) 24 (6.5)
Abandonment/neglect of care
Mother left alone for a period of time without care provider nearby while were in labor 110 (29.8) 259 (70.2)
Mother gave birth alone because the care providers were not present 17 (4.6) 352 (95.4)
Mother encountered a life-threatening condition for which she shouted for help but could not get anyone reached you in time 72 (19.5) 297 (80.5)
Detention in a health facility
Mother was detained or confined in health facility against her will 72 (19.5) 297 (80.5)