Table 6. Parameters selected by neurophysiological assessments investigating the effects of tSCS on spinal cord functioning in individuals with SCI.
Stimulation parameters selected by studies carrying out neurophysiological assessments into the properties of spinal cord stimulation with SCI participants.
ELECTRODES | STIMULATION PROTOCOL | ELECTRICAL CHARACTERISTICS | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Study | Patient position | Size/shape [Area] | Polarity | Location | Description | Frequency | Intensity | Phase Charge (μC) | Max Phase Charge Density (μC/cm2) |
Lower limb responses | |||||||||
Dy et al., 2010 [14] | Lying prone, BWS standing, BWS stepping | ø 2.5 cm [4.9 cm2] | Cathode | T11-T12 | Single, t1 = 1ms, mono square wave pulses | 1) Prone/ Standing: 0.5 Hz | 24.7 - 83mA | 25–83 | 16.9 |
Pair 5.0 x 10.2 cm | Anodes | Iliac crests | 2) Stepping: 0.25–0.33 Hz | Set to where consistent responses observed in all measured muscles in standing | |||||
Emeliannikov et al., 2016 [15] | Seated | - | - | T11-T12 | t1 = 1ms paired pulses (50ms inter-pulse interval) | 0.3 Hz for H-Reflex | 30–80 mA | 30–80 | - |
- | - | - | Lowest amplitude to completely supress the second stimulus of a pair | ||||||
Hofstoetter et al., 2018 [16] | Lying supine | Pair ø 5 cm [2 x 19.6 cm2] | Alternating (anode first pulse, cathode second) | T11-T12 paravertebrally | Charge balanced, symmetric biph rectangular t1 = 1ms | - | 32–86 mA Adjusted to reach target threshold >100uV in all muscle groups studied | 32–86 | 2.2 |
8 x 13 cm | Alternating | Para-umbilically lower abdomen | |||||||
Hofstoetter et al., 2019 [17] | Lying supine | 5 x 9 cm [45 cm2] | Alternating (anode first pulse, cathode second) | T11—T12 paravertebrally | Charge balanced, symmetric biph rectangular t1 = 1ms | - | Adjusted to elicit control-PRM reflexes in the right soleus with amplitudes that best matched the control-H reflexes and to elicit PRM reflexes in other muscles studied | - | - |
Pair 8 x 13 cm | Alternating | Lower abdomen | |||||||
Murray and Knikou, 2019 [20] | Lying supine | 10.2 x 5.1 cm [52 cm2] | Cathode | T10—L1/L2 | 1) Intervention: alternating suprathreshold and subthreshold stimulation (60 mins/session), mono square wave t1 = 1ms | 1) 0.2Hz | Selected based on threshold to produce right soleus evoked potential (96.9 ± 24 mA). Treatment sessions ranged from 0.4–4.3 times this resting threshold | 97 | 1.9 |
Connected pair 10.2 x 5.1 cm2 | Anode | Para-umbilically/ iliac crests | 2) Assessment: mono square wave t1 = 1ms | 2) 0.1, 0.125, 0.2, 0.33, 1.0 Hz | From below motor threshold until plateau reached | 417 | 8.0 | ||
Atkinson et al., 2020 [26] | Lying supine | ø 1.8 cm [2.6 cm2] | Cathode | Midline T9-T10 (n = 1), T10-T11(n = 7), T11-T12 (n = 6), T12-L1 (n = 1) | Single, mono square wave pulses, t1 = 1ms | - | 0-100mA or until response magnitude plateaued | 0 to 100 | 39.3 |
Pair 5 x 9 cm | Anode | Anterior superior iliac spines | |||||||
Militskova et al., 2020 [25] | Lying supine, BWS standing | ø 2.5 cm [4.9 cm2] | Stimulating | Midline T9-T10, T10-T11, T11-T12, T12-L1, and L1-L2 | Mono rectangular pulses t1 = 1ms | - | 30-100mA or maximum tolerated | 30 to 100 | 20.4 |
Pair 4 x 2 cm | Reference | Lower abdomen | |||||||
Islam et al., 2021 [72] | Lying supine, BWS stepping | 10.2 × 5.1 cm [52 cm2] | Cathode | Longitudinally between T10-L1 vertebrae | 1) Single mono pulses t1 = 1ms | 248 ± 87.06 mA for single pulses, | 248 ± 87.06 | 4.8 | |
pair 10.2 × 5.1 cm | Anode | Iliac crests or either side of abdominal muscles | 2) Pulse train of 12 1 ms pulses with a total duration of 33 ms randomly across the step cycle | 333.3 Hz | 57 to 160 mA for pulse trains Intensity set for Sol TEPs to be equivalent to the Sol H-reflex | 57 to 160 | 18.8 to 53 | ||
Upper limb responses | |||||||||
Wu et al., 2020 [23] | Seated | 5 x 10cm [50 cm2] | 1) Alternating polarity | 4cm caudal to C7 (T2-T4) | 1) Anode posterior 2ms, t1 = 1ms biph, | 0.2Hz | 80–175% of RMT, (RMT = 5.5–51 ma) | 89 μc mono | 1.8 |
2) Cathode posterior for majority | 2) Cathode posterior 2ms, t1 = 1ms biph, | 89 μc biph | 1.8 | ||||||
3) Cathode posterior t1 = 0.5ms biph, | |||||||||
5 x 10cm | 1) Alternating polarity | 1-2cm above sternal notch (C4-C5 levels anteriorly) | Threshold calculated as enough to elicit > 50uv in 5/10 reps | ||||||
2) Anode anterior for majority | |||||||||
4) Cathode posterior t1 = 1ms mono |
Abbreviations: biph; biphasic, mono; monophasic, PRM; posterior root-muscle, RMT; resting motor threshold, Sol; soleus, TEP; transpinal evoked potential. Where more than one test protocol existed within a given publication, the protocols were detailed using numerical listing: 1) 2) 3) etc. Phase charge density is given in terms of upper limits.