Table 3.
Mental health issue/measure | Significant deteriorationa | Significant improvementb | Non-significant change | % studies that support the YSIEc | Summary codes |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Depression | [73] | [57, 58, 60] | 25% | 0 | |
Anxiety | [74] | [58, 60] | 33% | 0 | |
Psychological distress | [75] | [57] | [76] | 33% | 0 |
Mood disorder | [74] | 0% | 0 | ||
Anxiety or mood disorder | [17] | [66] | 50% | ? | |
Either depression or anxiety | [88] | 100% | + | ||
Overall mental health | [20, 31, 65–67, 84, 90] | [68] | [57, 60] | 70% | + + |
Well-being | [65, 71] | 100% | + |
YSIE years since immigration effect
aInvolves either increase in mental health pathologies or decrease in overall mental health and well-being over years
bInvolves either reduction in mental health pathologies or improvement in general mental health and well-being over years
cNumber of studies supporting the predicted YSEI phenomenon divided by the whole number of studies examined each mental health outcome. + = evidence for presence of YSIE for the investigated mental health outcome (60–100% of papers supporting the predicted YSIE phenomenon); 0 = no evidence for presence of YSIE (0–33% of papers supporting the predicted YSIE phenomenon); ? = inconsistent evidence for presence of YSIE (34–59% of papers supporting the predicted YSIE phenomenon); Single signed codes (+ , 0, ?) were given when a significance evidence for presence of YSIE was found in less than four studies; Double signed summary coding (+ + , 00, ??) indicates that a significance evidence for presence of YSIE was revealed in four or more studies