Table 4.
Author, Year | No. of Patients | Condition | Treatment | Outcomes | Methods of Assessment |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Ibrahim 201813 | 35 | Atrophic post acne scars | PRP with micro-needling | Significant improvement in acne scars and facial aging. | Goodman and Baron’s global acne scarring system |
PRP with micro-needling had significantly lesser erythema and edema compared to than micro-needling alone | |||||
Min 201815 | 25 | Acne scars | PRP with fractional CO2 laser treatment | Significant improvement, Patient satisfaction scores were also significantly higher in PRP and CO2 laser treatment than CO2 treatment alone. | Investigator global assessment scale, Patient satisfaction scores |
Abdel Aal 201816 | 30 | Acne scars | PRP with fractional CO2 laser treatment | Combination of fractional CO2 laser resurfacing and intradermal PRP was superior to CO2 laser alone for acne scar treatment | Evaluation was carried out through operating physicians, two blinded physicians as well as through patient’s satisfaction. |
El-Domyati 201811 | 24 | Atrophic acne scars | PRP with micro-needling | Improvement of dermal structures, combination with trichloroacetic acid more effective than PRP | Photography and punch biopsies |
Al Taweel 201821 | 40 | Atrophic acne scars | PRP combined with carboxytherapy and PRP with CO2 laser treatment | PRP combined with CO2 laser treatment significantly improved acne scars compared with PRP combined with carboxytherapy treatment. | Photographs and patient satisfaction score |
Tenna 201725 | 30 | Atrophic acne scars | Fat grafts with PRP | Improved scars by increasing skin and subcutaneous tissue thickness | FACE-Q postoperative module was administered to analyze each patient’s satisfaction |
Asif 201612 | 50 | Atrophic scars | PRP with micro-needling | Significant improvement in atrophic acne scars. Patient satisfaction scores were also significantly different between PRP and micro-needling | Goodman’s qualitative and quantitative scales |
Faghihi 201617 | 16 | Atrophic acne scars: | PRP with fractional CO2 laser treatment | Clinical improvement of acne scars was higher on the platelet-rich plasma-fractional CO2 laser treated side but the difference was not statistically significant. | Patient satisfaction and the objective evaluation of serial photographs |
Zhu 201322 | 22 | Acne or acne scar | PRP with fractional CO2 laser treatment | Improvement of >50%, and 91% of the patients were satisfied with the treatment. | Comparing pre- and post-treatment photographs of the patients |
Lee 201118 | 14 | Acne scars | PRP with fractional CO2 laser treatment | Enhanced recovery of laser-damaged skin and synergistically improved the clinical appearance of acne scarring. | Dermatologists evaluated clinical improvement using a quartile grading scale |
El-Domyati 201810 | 24 | Facial wrinkles and other signs of photoaging | PRP with micro-needling | Significant clinical improvement after treatment | Photography and punch biopsies |
Deshmukh 201839 | 40 | Atrophic acne scars | PRP with subcutaneous incision-less surgery (subcision) | Significant improvement was observed in PRP plus subcision compared with subcision alone. | Goodman and Baron’s qualitative acne scar grading system |
Kar 201720 | 30 | Atrophic acne scars | PRP with fractional CO2 laser treatment | Significant improvement on both sides of the face. | Goodman and Barons quantitative global acne scar grading system |
Willemsen 201826 | 32 | Loss of skin elasticity and tissue volume | PRP with lipofilling | No improvement in the outcome about skin elasticity, graft volume maintenance, and patient satisfaction, however, the recovery time was significantly reduced due to addition of PRP | Changes in skin elasticity, volumetric changes of the nasolabial fold, recovery time, and patient satisfaction |
Ali 201832 | 63 | Facial aging | PRP with thread-lifting | Highly augmented results are observed when combined with PRP | Patient satisfaction |
Ibrahim 20179 | 90 | Atrophic post-acne scars, atrophic post-traumatic scars, post chickenpox scars | PRP with micro-needling | Significant improvement in the appearance of atrophic scars | Clinical evaluation scale score |
Ulusal 201735 | 94 | Facial aging | PRP with hyaluronic acid | Significant improvement was observed regarding the general appearance | 5-grade wrinkle severity rating scale and by patient satisfaction scores. |
Hui 201719 | 13 | Facial aging | PRP with fractional CO2 laser treatment | Subjective scores of facial wrinkles, skin texture, and skin elasticity were higher | Satisfaction scores, dermatologists’ double-blind evaluation and the VISIA skin analysis system |
Kamakura 201536 | 2005 | Wrinkles and depression in the skin | PRP with growth factor | Level of patient satisfaction was 97.3% and the level of investigator satisfaction was 98.4%. | Global Aesthetic Improvement Scale, Wrinkle Severity Rating Scale |
Willemsen 201427 | 82 | Loss of tissue volume, significant ptosis, and the subsequent descent of tissues | PRP with fat grafting | Significant drop in the number of days needed to recover. | Questionnaire based evaluation |
van Dongen 202159 | 28 | Facial aging | PRP supplemented lipofilling with stromal vascular fraction | In comparison to PRP-supplemented lipofilling, PRP-supplemented lipofilling combined with stromal vascular fraction does not improve facial skin quality or patient satisfaction. | Changes in skin elasticity and transepidermal water loss, changes in skin-aging-related features, ie, superficial spots, wrinkles, skin texture, pores, vascularity, and pigmentation, as well as patient satisfaction (FACE-Q), recovery, and number of complications |
Abdel-Maguid 202137 | 33 | Atrophic acne scars. | PRP with fractional CO2 laser | Better and faster improvement, dermal collagen and procollagen type 1 was increased after PRP therapy | Clinical assessment and Skin biopsies |
Sasaki 201930 | 10 | Facial aging | PRP with fat grafting | Improvement in the average percent change in mean volume assessments at the fat/PRP sites from baseline values | 3D Vectra Analysis, VISIA, and Cortex facial skin analyses |
El-Taieb 201923 | 75 | Atrophic acne scars | PRP with erbium laser | Improvement with combined treatment was better than that with erbium-YAG laser or platelet-rich plasma alone | Acne scar grading, photography, and subjective evaluation. |
Rigotti 201628 | 13 | Facial aging | PRP with fat grafting | Presence of more pronounced inflammatory infiltrates and a greater vascular reactivity, increasing in vascular permeability and a certain reactivity of the nervous component. | Clinical observation, optical and electron microscopy |
Alam 201814 | 27 | Facial aging | PRP with micro-needling | Improved the visual appearance in individuals with photoaged skin, fine and coarse texture improved significantly. | Photoaging scores, self-assessment scores of improvements on a 5-point scale |
Abbreviations: CO2, carbon-dioxide; PRP, platelet-rich plasma.