Table 3.
Author and Year | Aim | Study Design |
Sample | Studied Drug | Major Side Effect | Studied Risk | Recommendation |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Nichols et al., 2007 | Insomnia management strategies description | Narrative review | Cognitive therapy Antihistamines Anti-depressants Bz* AgoBz** Melatonin agonist receptor |
Anticholinergic effects in the elderly Sedation Daytime sleepiness Tolerance Dependence |
Cardiovascular complications Adverse Breathing Events Delirium Abuse |
Cognitive therapy AgoBz** | |
Hayes et al., 2009 | Review of the effects of medication on SD in HF patients | Narrative review | Medications for the management of HF Medication for the management of insomina Cognitive therapy |
Tolerance, dependence and rebound insomnia | Daytime sleepiness | AgoBz** have fewer adverse events than Bz* | |
De Pablos et al., 2009 | Description of therapies used in patients >65 with respiratory and cardiac insufficiencies with insomnia and/or anxiety | Narrative review | Bz* AgoBz** Serotonergic Anxiolytics Antihistamines Clomethiazole |
Sleepiness, decreased mental acuity and motor skills | Dependence and withdrawal in short lived Bz | Lorazepam, zolpidem, clomethiazole | |
Ishak et al., 2012 | Study of the impact of insomnia on the quality of life | Systematic review | 58 | Bz* Non-pharmacological treatment |
Psychiatric or physical comorbidity. Increased medication or psychosocial problem | Long-term dependence and tolerance. Deteriorating quality of life. Increased morbidity and mortality |
AgoBz** to address insomnia. |
Garrido et al., 2014 | Study of inappropriate use of Bz* in >65 | Descriptive | 222 | Psychotropics Bz* |
Dependence, cognitive impairment, ataxia, syncope, falls, delirium and readmission to hospital | Use Bz* and AgoBz** | Reduce Bz* prescription Strict control of Bz* treatment in the long term |
Chung et al., 2015 | To assess the effects of hypnotics on the risk of adverse events in patients with cardiopulmonary problems | Retrospective analytical case control study | 22.684 | Bz* and no Bz* | Pneumonia Acute Exacerbation Acute respiratory failure Cardiorespiratory arrest |
High risk of adverse respiratory events | Medical management of hypnotic treatment of patients with cardiorespiratory problems |
Gatti et al., 2016 | To assess the effects of zolpidem in patients with HF and sleep disorder | Double-blind, randomized, placebo-controlled analysis | 15 | Zolpidem | No adverse effects | Possible adverse effects | No adverse effects using Zolpidem |
Buxo et al. 2018 | Prevalence of insomnia in HF patients studied | Descriptive | 68 | Non-pharmacological measures | |||
Motter et al., 2018 | Study of potentially inappropriate drugs in >65 | Systematic review | 36 | Bz* | Cognitive impairment, Respiratory failure | Falls, fractures, delirium | Avoid using Bz* |
Bz* = Benzodiazepine; AgoBz** = Bz receptor agonists.