Skip to main content
. 2021 Nov 18;11(11):1525. doi: 10.3390/brainsci11111525

Table 5.

Comparison of studies conducted for the seizure detection task by using shared data sets.

Database Authors Year Feature Extraction Method Classification Performance (%)
BONN Hamed et al. [179] 2018 DWT RBF-SVM Accuracy = 100
Savadkoohi et al. [184] 2020 FFT / WT SVM Accuracy = 100
Jaiswal and Banka [180] 2018 PCA RBF-SVM Accuracy = 100
Riaz et al. [182] 2015 EMD SVM High performance in the detection of seizures in case 1 and 2
Ullah et al. [266] 2018 - 1D-CNN Accuracy = 99.1
Lu and Triesch [265] 2019 - Residual CNN Accuracy = 99
Chakraborty and Mitra [185] 2021 VMD RF Accuracy = 98.7–100
Ech-Choudany et al. [186] 2021 Dissimilarity-based TFD LDA Accuracy = 98
Mardini et al. [183] 2020 DWT ANNs Accuracy = 97.8
Liu et al. [181] 2017 WPD ELM Accuracy = 97.7
Murugappan and Ramakrishnan [118] 2016 WT H-MSVM Accuracy = 94
Kaya and Ertugrul [187] 2018 1D-TP RF Accuracy > 94
CHB-MIT Pinto-Orellana and Cerqueira [190] 2016 PCA RF Sensitivity = 97.1 Specificity = 99.2
Shoeb et al. [191] 2011 - SVM Sensitivity = 96
Fergus et al. [189] 2015 PCA KNN Sensitivity = 93 Specificity = 94
Usman et al. [192] 2017 EMD SVM Sensitivity = 92.2 Specificity = 93.4
European Epilepsy Teixeira et al. [199] 2014 WT ANNs Sensitivity = 73.1
Direito et al. [198] 2017 DWT Linear-SVM High performance in a small subset of participants
Bandarabadi et al. [200] 2015 MDADH SVM Sensitivity = 73.98