Skip to main content
. 2021 Nov 22;11(11):469. doi: 10.3390/bios11110469

Table 1.

The table displays for each included study.

Study Disease Sensor Case Control Sensitivity Specificity
Mommers [26], 2020 Aneurysm and recurrent hernia Metal-oxide 64 a 74 0.81 0.73
Wong [27], 2019 Appendicitis Conductive polymer 5 45 0.8 0.8
Montuschi [28], 2010 Asthma Quartz microbalances 30 21 0.87 0.95
Barash [29], 2015 Breast cancer Gold nanoparticles and carbon nanotubes 169 82 0.88 0.83
Yang [5], 2021 Breast cancer Carbon nanotubes 70 b 18 a 0.86 b 0.97 b
Fielding [30], 2020 Bronchial and laryngeal cancer Carbon nanotubes 42 13 0.95 0.69
Amal [6], 2016 Colorectal cancer Gold nanoparticles and carbon nanotubes 20 b 36 b 0.94 b 0.91 b
Shafiek [31], 2015 COPD Carbon nanotubes 124 30 0.69 0.75
Binson [10], 2021 COPD and lung cancer Metal-oxide 70 144 0.81 0.94
Welearegay [32], 2018 Cutaneous leishmaniasis Metal nanoparticles 28 a 28 0.96 1
Welearegay [33], 2019 Echinococcosis Metal nanoparticles 36 40 0.97 0.98
van Dartel [34], 2020 Epilepsy Metal-oxide 74 110 0.76 0.67
Broza [8], 2019 Gastric cancer Gold nanoparticles 102 1065 0.82 0.79
Xu [35], 2013 Gastric cancer Gold nanoparticles and carbon nanotubes 37 93 0.89 0.9
Leja [36], 2021 Gastric cancer Gold nanoparticles 47 105 0.92 0.86
Umapathy [37], 2019 Haemodialysis Metal-oxide 21 17 0.86 0.29
Gruber [38], 2014 Head and neck cancer Nanomaterial-based sensor 22 19 0.77 0.9
Leunis [39], 2014 Head and neck cancer Metal-oxide 36 23 0.9 0.8
Hakim [9], 2011 Head-and-neck cancer and lung cancer Gold nanoparticles 36 a 52 1 0.92
Finamore [40], 2018 Heart failure Quartz microbalances 30 b 39 b 0.8 b 0.82 b
Moor [11], 2021 Interstitial lung disease Metal-oxide 322 48 1 1
De Vincentis [12], 2016 Liver cirrhosis Quartz microbalances 58 56 1 0.98
Zaim [41], 2021 Liver cirrhosis WO3 nanowires 22 32 0.97 1
Gasparri [42], 2016 Lung cancer Quartz microbalances 72 74 0.88 1
Huang [4], 2018 Lung cancer Carbon nanotubes 56 188 0.92 0.93
Hubers [43], 2014 Lung cancer Carbon nanotubes 38 39 0.87 0.43
Kononov [44], 2020 Lung cancer Metal-oxide 19 b 17 b 0.95 b 1 b
Rocco [45], 2016 Lung cancer Quartz microbalances 23 77 0.86 0.95
Shlomi [46], 2017 Lung cancer Gold nanoparticles and carbon nanotubes 16 30 0.75 0.93
Tan [47], 2016 Lung cancer Metal-oxide 12 13 0.83 0.88
Broza et al. [48], 2017 Multiple sclerosis Gold nanoparticles 128 58 0.76 0.81
Nakhleh et al. [49], 2015 Parkinson’s disease Gold nanoparticles and carbon nanotubes 16 37 0.81 0.76
Ionescu et al. [50], 2011 Multiple sclerosis Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons and single-wall carbon nanotubes 34 17 0.85 0.71
Amal et al. [51], 2015 Ovarian cancer Gold nanoparticles and carbon nanotubes 48 48 0.85 0.65
Raspagliesi et al. [7], 2020 Ovarian cancer Metal-oxide 86 114 0.98 0.95
Yang et al. [52], 2018 Pneumoconiosis Carbon nanotubes 34 64 0.68 0.84
Nakhleh et al. [53], 2016 Preeclampsia Gold nanoparticles 31 31 0.92 0.91
Broza et al. [54], 2018 Rhinosinusitis Gold nanoparticles and carbon nanotubes 17 30 0.76 0.8
Zamora-Mendoza et al. [55], 2022 SARS-CoV-2 Carbon nanotubes 42 30 0.97 1
Shan et al. [14], 2020 SARS-CoV-2 Gold nanoparticles 41 57 1 0.81
Wintjens et al. [56], 2020 SARS-CoV-2 Metal-oxide 57 162 0.86 0.54
Tsai et al. [57], 2021 Small airway dysfunction Carbon nanotubes 12 60 0.92 0.95
Chen et al. [13], 2020 Ventilator-associated pneumonia Carbon nanotubes 33 26 0.72 0.77
Schnabel et al. [58], 2015 Ventilator-associated pneumonia Metal-oxide 33 53 0.88 0.66

a Included data from the model for two disease outcomes. b Data derived from a test database.