Skip to main content
. 2021 Nov 11;22(22):12200. doi: 10.3390/ijms222212200

Table 5.

Comparison of different synthetic strategies of 3D matrix-based.

Fabrication Method Method Overview Scaffolding Morphology Advantages Disadvantages
Hydrogels [11,54,193,279,280,281] -Collagen gel solution (usually type 1 collagen and acetic acid) mixed on ice and usually neutralized (NaOH) and then gelled
-Physical parameters: collagen, pH, the temperature of desired gelling
-Dense gel network of string-like fibers. The thickness of the fiber depends on the manufacturing parameters -Easy to apply
-Matrigel is widely used in cancer research, so many user guides are available
-High level of cell viability
-The least porous
-Risk of poor distribution of cells and nutrients.
-An architecture is more difficult to control, therefore, has less reproducibility of the exact architectures desired
-Poor mechanical properties before cross-linking
Lyophilization
[153,276,292,293,294,295,296,297,298]
-Creation of a homogeneous suspension of collagen with acid (usually acetic acid) at high speed
-Heat treatment (controlled or quenched) for the sublimation of ice crystals under vacuum to the defined freezing point before returning to ~0 °C
The dried scaffolding must reach room temperature to complete the process
-Interconnected network
-Highly porous
-A well-defined pore shape and sizes
-Good control of scaffolding architecture
-A wide production range in terms of pore sizes and orientation
-High porosity levels.
-Inexpensive-High level of cell viability
-Problems in the freezing process affect the final scaffolding architecture from one batch to another
-Poor mechanical properties before cross-linking
Electrospiding [299,300,301,302,303,304,305,306,307,308,309,310,311,312] -Collagen solubilized (usually HFIP or TFE) and added to the syringe/injection system
-A high-voltage electric field is applied, causing the charge of the solution, the eruption of the polymer fiber of the tip of the needle, and the whip of the liquid jet
-The solvent evaporates during the process, leaving a network of dried fibers deposited on the collection plate (non-woven or aligned)
-Dense and tight fiber array (chain-shaped) of nanometric or micro size -Fibrous network that closely resembles native collagen fibers.
-Wide range of size/diameter/achievable fiber pattern
-High level of reported cell viability
-Use of harmful solvents (collagen scaffolding)
-Solvents are expensive
-Dense fiber networks can reduce the level of cellular infiltration.
Stereolithography [277,313,314,315,316,317,318,319] -prints layer by layer a UV-curable material in thin sheets
-Installation of a multiresolution 3D printer (Dilase 3D, Kloe France)
-Each layer is superimposed after drying the next layer
-Use of different light sources (visible, UV, IR) capable of polymerizing photosensitive materials.
-Hard layer set (UV) -Capable of producing scaffolding of size mm to cm
-Can be combined with different components to hydrogels or electro spinning (PCL fibers, PCL /gelatin)
-high differentiation rates and adhesion
-Imitates complex structures in vitro: as villi of the intestine
-Specific equipment
-Expensive
-Manufactured scaffolding is usually limited to a few tens of microns of resolution
Micro fluid [278,320,321,322,323,324,325,326,327,328,329,330,331,332,333] Support consisting of silicon/elastomer-based devices having microchannels with proportions from 1 to 1000 μm that exploit a small volume of fluids (10-9 to 10-18 L). These fluids are continuous flows of nutrients and therapeutic agents, establish a physiological profile such as that of blood circulation and intravenous injections -Matrix that has micro channels- which can be either strictly laminar (in parallel layers) or turbulent (parallel and strong numbers) -Labor-saving
-Microenvironment dynamics (fluid flow)
-Generate aggregates of different forms Co-culture of several cells
-Simulates cell-cell contacts and biological signals controlled by spatial and temporal gradients of soluble biological factors
-Study tumor progression, invasion, angiogenesis as well as treatment tests
-Low reagent consumption and low cell utilization
-Requiring professional equipment and special design
-Complexity.
-High cost