Table 3.
Comparison of the different CAPA diagnostic algorithms.
| Author | Author’s Classification/No. of Cases |
AspICU (Blot et al.) |
Modified AspICU (Verweij et al.) |
IAPA (Schauwvlieghe et al.) |
ECMM/ISHAM (Koehler et al.) |
CAPA (White et al.) |
EORTC (Donnelly et al.) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bartoletti et al. | mAspICU/ 30 probable |
2 proven 28 NC |
28 probable 2 proven |
28 probable 2 proven |
28 probable 2 proven |
17 putative 2 proven 11 NC |
2 proven 28 NC |
| Chen et al. | NR/ 1 CAPA NS |
No data | No data | No data | No data | No data | No data |
| Koehler et al. | AspICU personal/ 5 putative |
3 colonisation 2 NC |
4 probable 1 NC |
4 probable 1 NC |
4 probable 1 possible |
5 putative | 5 NC |
| Lahmer et al. | AspICU personal/ 11 putative |
11 colonisation | 11 probable | 11 probable | 11 probable | 9 putative 2 NC |
11 NC |
| Rutsaert et al. | AspICU/ 4 proven 3 putative |
4 proven 1 putative 1 colonisation 1 NC |
4 proven 2 probable |
4 proven 2 probable |
4 proven 2 probable 1 possible |
4 proven 1 putative 2 NC |
4 proven 3 NC |
| Alanio et al. | AspICU personal/ 9 putative |
2 putative 5 colonisation 2 NC |
6 probable 3 NC |
6 probable 3 NC |
6 probable 2 possible 1 NC |
6 putative 3 NC |
1 probable 8 NC |
| Brown et al. | IAPA/ 2 probable |
2 colonisation | 2 NC | 2 probable | 2 possible | 2 putative | 2 NC |
| Van Arkel et al. | mAspICU/ 3 probable |
4 colonisation 2 NC |
3 probable 3 NC |
3 probable 3 NC |
3 probable 2 possible 1 NC |
3 putative 3 NC |
6 NC |
| Nasir et al. | NR/ 5 putative 4 colonisation |
9 colonisation | 9 NC | 9 NC | 5 possible | 2 putative 3 NC |
5 NC |
| Gangneux et al. | AspICU pers./ 4 putative 3 probable |
9 putative 6 NC |
7 probable 8 NC |
7 probable 8 NC |
15 probable | 7 putative 8 NC |
1 probable 14 NC |
| Falces-Romero et al. | AspICU/EORTC/ 7 putative 1 probable 2 NC |
9 colonised 1 NC |
2 probable 8 NC |
2 probable 8 NC |
2 probable 7 possible 1 NC |
2 putative 8 NC |
1 probable 9 NC |
| Zhang et al. | NR/ 3 CAPA NS |
No data | No data | No data | No data | No data | No data |
| White et al. | CAPA/ 19 putative |
8 putative 3 colonised 14 NC |
20 probable 5 NC |
20 probable 5 NC |
22 probable 3 NC |
19 putative | 1 probable 24 NC |
| Ichai et al. | NR/ 6 probable/proven |
No data | No data | No data | No data | No data | No data |
| Sarrazyn et al. | AspICU/ 4 putative |
4 colonisation | 4 probable | 4 probable | 4 probable | 4 putative | 4 NC |
| Dupont et al. | AspICU pers./ 19 putative |
2 putative 14 colonised 3 NC |
12 probable 7 NC |
11 probable 8 NC |
11 probable 8 possible |
4 putative 15 NC |
19 NC |
| Mitaka et al. | AspICU/ 4 putative |
4 putative | 4 probable | 4 probable | 4 probable | 1 putative 3 NC |
4 NC |
| Borman et al. | AspICU pers./ 14 probable 1 possible |
1 putative 3 colonised 11 NC |
8 probable 7 NC |
8 probable 7 NC |
9 probable 1 possible 5 NC |
9 putative 6 NC |
15 NC |
| Rothe et al. | NR/ 9 CAPA NS |
No data | No data | No data | No data | No data | No data |
| Wang et al. | EORTC/ 8 possible |
4 colonisation 4 NC |
4 probable 4 NC |
4 probable 4 NC |
4 probable 4 NC |
4 putative 4 NC |
8 possible |
| Chauvet et al. | Multiple/ 5 putative 1 possible |
3 putative 1 colonised 2 NC |
3 probable 3 NC |
3 probable 3 NC |
3 probable 2 possible 1 NC |
2 putative 4 NC |
1 probable 1 possible 4 NC |
| Machado et al. | AspICU/ 8 putative |
8 putative | 6 probable 2 NC |
6 probable 2 NC |
6 probable 2 possible |
6 putative 2 NC |
1 probable 5 NC |
| Segrelles-Calvo et al. | EORTC/ 7 probable |
No data | No data | No data | No data | No data | No data |
| Roman-Montes et al. | IAPA/ 14 probable |
10 colonised 4 NC |
6 probable 8 NC |
6 probable 8 NC |
6 probable 8 possible |
13 putative 1 NC |
14 NC |
| Permpalung et al. | Personal/ 20 probable 19 possible |
No data | No data | No data | No data | No data | No data |
| Delliere et al. | mAspICU + EORTC/ 21 probable |
2 putative 17 colonised 2 NC |
19 probable 3 NC |
16 probable 5 NC |
16 probable 5 possible |
13 putative 8 NC |
2 probable 19 NC |
| Falcone et al. | NR/ 1 CAPA NS |
No data | No data | No data | No data | No data | No data |
| Fekkar et al. | EORTC/ 6 probable |
4 putative 2 colonised |
4 probable 2 NC |
4 probable 2 NC |
5 probable 1 possible |
6 putative | 4 probable 2 NC |
| Gouzien et al. | mAspICU/ 2 probable |
1 putative 1 colonised |
2 probable | 2 probable | 2 probable | 2 NC | 2 probable |
| Van Grootveld et al. | ECMM/ 11 probable 8 NC |
1 putative 10 colonised 8 NC |
10 probable 9 NC |
10 probable 9 NC |
11 probable 4 possible 4 NC |
10 putative 9 NC |
19 NC |
| Maes et al. | IAPA/ 3 probable |
3 NC | 3 probable | 3 probable | 3 probable | 3 NC | 3 NC |
| Meijer et al. | ECMM/ 13 probable |
13 colonised | 8 probable 5 NC |
8 probable 5 NC |
8 probable 5 possible |
10 putative 3 NC |
13 NC |
| Van Biesen et al. | Personal/ 9 putative |
1 putative 6 colonised 2 NC |
9 probable | 9 probable | 9 probable | 7 putative | 9 NC |
| Obata et al. | NR/ 4 CAPA NS |
No data | No data | No data | No data | No data | No data |
| Razazi et al. | mAspICU/IAPA 7 probable |
2 putative 4 colonised 1 NC |
6 probable 1 NC |
6 probable 1 NC |
6 probable 1 NC |
7 NC | 7 NC |
| Ripa et al. | AspICU personal/ 11 putative |
No data | No data | No data | No data | No data | No data |
| Pintado et al. | ECMM/ 16 probable |
No data | No data | No data | 16 probable | No data | No data |
| Versych et al. | IAPA/ 2 probable |
2 colonised | 2 probable | 2 probable | 2 probable | 2 putative | 2 NC |
| Reizine et al. | ECMM/ 10 probable |
9 colonised 1 NC |
3 probable 7 NC |
3 probable 7 NC |
4 probable 6 possible |
10 putative | 10 NC |
| Oliva et al. | mAspICU/IAPA 2 probable |
2 NC | 2 probable | 2 probable | 1 probable 1 NC |
2 NC | 2 NC |
| Campochiaro et al. | NR/ 1 CAPA NS |
1 colonised | 1 probable | 1 probable | 1 probable | 1 NC | 1 NC |
| Wasylyshyn et al. | ECMM/ 3 probable |
2 colonised 1 NC |
2 probable 1 NC |
2 probable 1 NC |
2 probable 1 possible |
2 putative 1 NC |
2 NC |
| Nebreda-Moyoral et al. | NR/ 3 CAPA |
3 colonised | 3 NC | 3 NC | 3 possible | 3 NC | 3 NC |
| Signorini et al. | EORTC/ 2 probable |
No data | No data | No data | No data | No data | 2 probable |
| Rabagliati et al. | ECMM/ 14 probable |
7 colonised 7 NC |
8 probable 6 NC |
8 probable 6 NC |
7 probable 7 possible |
4 putative 10 NC |
14 NC |
| Lamoth et al. | mAspICU personal/ 1 probable 2 putative |
3 colonised | 1 probable 2 NC |
1 probable 2 NC |
1 probable 2 possible |
2 putative | 3 NC |
| Yang et al. | NR/ 2 CAPA NS |
No data | No data | No data | No data | No data | No data |
| Total | 395 cases, of which 6 proven | 49 putative 163 colonised |
211 probable | 206 probable | 236 probable 79 possible |
180 putative | 16 probable 9 possible |
Abbreviations. NS, not specified; NC, not classifiable.