Study ID | Description of components within study | Components not included or combined with others | Intervention delivery | Included components |
Abizanda 2011 | Occupational therapy intervention consisted of a daily session with patient and relative/caregiver Monday‐Friday for the duration of admission. Activities were carried out according to needs and day of admission. Therapeutic plan included: cognitive stimulation; instruction on preventing complications including immobility, confusion, falls, urinary incontinence, pressure sores; retraining in ADL; assessment of technical aids for home |
Education Tailored | Bowel/bladder care Cognitive stimulation Mobilisation |
|
Avendano‐Cespedes 2016 | The intervention was carried out exclusively by the intervention nurses and was composed of two main parts, being the first one a risk factor analysis, and the second one the intervention on the risk factors detected. Risk factors: orientation, sensorial deficit, sleep, mobilisation, hydration, nutrition, drugs, oxygenation, elimination, and pain |
Education Tailored |
Bowel/bladder care Medication review Mobilisation Nutrition & hydration Oxygenation Pain control Re‐orientation & familiar objects Reducing sensory deprivation Sleep hygiene |
|
Bonaventura 2007 | Intervention to Prevent Delirium (IPD), a series of structured and standardised welfare actions based on existing guidelines, including support in the following areas: cognitive re‐orientation, sensory and environmental, mobilisation, hydration, and ’socio‐emotional’ | Familiar objects | Education | Mobilisation Nutrition & hydration Re‐orientation & familiar objects Reducing sensory deprivation Sleep hygiene |
Chen 2017 | Modified Hospital Elder Life Program comprising of three standardised protocols: orienting communication (i.e., orientation and engaged conversation), oral and nutritional assistance (i.e., brushing teeth, oral‐facial exercise, and postoperative dietary education), and early mobilization. | Education Protocol/checklist |
Mobilisation Nutrition & hydration Re‐orientation & familiar objects |
|
Dong 2020 | All patients received 1. Directional communication plan 2. Cognitive therapy activity plan 3. Early activity plan The following schemes are implemented as needed based on the evaluation results 4. Pain improvement program 5. Sleep improvement program 6. Assisted feeding plan 7. Rehydration program 8. Constipation improvement plan 9. Hearing/vision improvement program 10. Hypoxic improvement program 11. Aspiration pneumonia prevention program 12. Urine‐related infection prevention program 13. Delirium improvement program 14. Dementia improvement program 15. Multiple medication management plan |
Protocol/checklist Tailored |
Bowel/bladder care Medication review Mobilisation Nutrition & hydration Oxygenation Pain control Reducing sensory deprivation Sleep hygiene |
|
Hempenius 2013 | Multi‐component intervention focused on best supportive care and the prevention of delirium. Preoperative geriatric team assessment with daily monitoring during hospital stay, supported by the use of standardised checklists. This checklist consisted of nine items: orientation, mobility, anxiety, senses, pain, sleep, intake, defecation and infection. |
Comprehensive Geriatric Assessment Education Protocol/checklist Tailored |
Assessment of mood Bowel/bladder care Identification of infection Medication review Mobilisation Nutrition & hydration Pain control Re‐orientation & familiar objects Reducing sensory deprivation Sleep hygiene |
|
Hosie 2020 | The intervention had six domains 1. Preserve natural sleep 2. Maintain optimal sensory perception 3. Optimise hydration 4. Stimulate communication, orientation and cognition 5. Optimise mobility 6. Family partnership For each domain there are 4‐12 strategies provided and their implementation is described We asked team members to enlist family and volunteers and tailor the intervention to patients’ needs and wishes. |
Education Family involvement Multidisciplinary Protocol/checklist |
Mobilisation Nutrition & hydration Re‐orientation & familiar objects Reducing sensory deprivation Sleep hygiene |
|
Jeffs 2013 | Participants received a graded physical activity and orientation programme twice daily, which was delivered in addition to usual care. A certified Allied Health Assistant, trained in administering exercise programmes, delivered the intervention after initial assessment of the participant by a physiotherapist. Commensurate with ability, participants were prescribed one of four exercise programmes: bed, seated, standing or rails. All programmes were customised to the participant’s ability and were reviewed daily. Exercise programmes were modified to ensure suitable progression for those participants who made significant gains. The orientation programme comprised formal and informal elements. The formal element of the programme comprised a series of seven questions aimed at assessing and improving orientation (day, month, year, date, ward, bed number and name of primary nurse). The participant was asked the questions in sequence and prompted with the correct answer if they were not able to give a correct response. The informal element of the programme related to engaging in the exercise programme and in the social interaction with the Allied Health Assistant and/or Physiotherapist. |
Protocol/checklist | Mobilisation Re‐orientation & familiar objects |
|
Lundstrom 2007 | The staff worked as a team, applying comprehensive geriatric assessment, management and rehabilitation. Main content of the intervention ‐ Prevention and treatment of complications, bowel and bladder function, sleep, decubitus ulcers, pain, saturation, body temperature, Blood pressure, nutrition, rehabilitation, Secondary prevention of falls and fractures and osteoporosis prophylaxis. Other – staff education, teamwork, individual care planning, delirium |
Comprehensive Geriatric Assessment Education Multidisciplinary Protocol/checklist Tailored |
Bowel/bladder care Identification of infection Mobilisation Nutrition & hydration Oxygenation Pain control Sleep hygiene |
|
Marcantonio 2001 | Proactive geriatrics consultation. The consultation included 10 modules – adequate CNS oxygen delivery, fluid electrolyte balance, treatment of severe pain, elimination of unnecessary medications, regulation of bowel/bladder function, adequate nutritional intake, early mobilisation and rehabilitation, prevention, early detection and treatment of major postoperative complications, appropriate environmental stimuli, treatment of agitated delirium. |
Electrolytes Postoperative complications |
Tailored | Bowel/bladder care Cognitive stimulation Identification of infection Medication review Mobilisation Nutrition & hydration (including electrolyte balance) Oxygenation Pain control Re‐orientation & familiar objects Reducing sensory deprivation |
Martinez 2012 | Multicomponent management protocol. The intervention was delivered by family members and consisted of 6 elements: 1. Education 2. Provision of a clock 3. Avoidance of sensory deprivation 4. Presence of familiar objects in the room 5. Reorientation of patient provided by family members 6. Extended visitation time. |
Familiar objects | Education Family involvement Multidisciplinary Protocol/checklist |
Cognitive stimulation Re‐orientation & familiar objects Reducing sensory deprivation |
Partridge 2017 | Comprehensive geriatric assessment delivered by a multidisciplinary team (geriatrician, clinical nurse specialist, social worker, occupational therapist) according to individual patient. Patients were assessed and optimised according to peer‐reviewed protocols based on current evidence, national and hospital guidelines, and expert opinion. The domains that were included cognition, general health status, function independence, social support, medication use, nutrition and mood. |
Comprehensive Geriatric Assessment Multidisciplinary Tailored |
Assessment of mood Cognitive stimulation Medication review Mobilisation Nutrition & hydration |
|
Wang 2020 | t‐Hospital Elder Life Program (HELP) (tailored, family‐involved HELP), which involved family members instead of volunteers and applied a tailored approach to assigning HELP protocols. The t‐HELP intervention consisted of 3 universal protocols and 8 targeted protocols. The universal protocols, including orientation, therapeutic activities, and early mobilisation protocol (universal protocols), were given to all t‐HELP participants. The targeted protocols were tailored for each patient on the basis of delirium related risk factors, which were assessed daily and comprised of pain management, sleep enhancement, nutrition assistance/aspiration prevention, fluid repletion/constipation, vision/hearing enhancement, hypoxia Improvement, catheter associated UTI (CAUTI) prevention and multiple medications management. |
Education Family involvement Multidisciplinary Protocol/checklist Tailored |
Bowel/bladder care Identification of infection Medication review Mobilisation Nutrition & hydration Oxygenation Pain control Re‐orientation & familiar objects Sleep hygiene |
|
Young 2020 | The Prevention of Delirium (POD) programme is a manualised, multicomponent intervention and systematic implementation process designed to secure ward practice changes consistent with a reduction in delirium. POD comprises actions centred on ten risk factors associated with the development of delirium among those who are vulnerable on of the basis of predisposing risk (NICE 2010). These interventions directly affect the patient experience of care and include optimising hydration and nutrition, reducing environmental triggers (excessive noise, multiple moves), increasing orientation to time and place, improving communicative practices (personally meaningful interaction and cognitive stimulation), supporting and/or encouraging mobility and better management of pain and infection. |
Education Protocol/checklist |
Cognitive stimulation Identification of infection Mobilisation Nutrition & hydration Pain control Re‐orientation & familiar objects Reducing sensory deprivation Sleep hygiene |