Table 1.
Summary of the different models to study toxic effects on the human placental barrier.
Models | Interests in Toxicology Studies | Advantages | Drawbacks |
---|---|---|---|
Animal models | • impact on pregnancy and outcomes • fetotoxicity studies |
• in vivo • low cost • chronic exposure possible |
• cautious extrapolation to animal model in view of the specificity of human placentation |
Ex-vivo placental perfusion | • transplacental passage • placental kinetics and metabolism • placental accumulation of pollutants |
• access to organized placental tissue (a whole cotyledon perfused) | • only possible in term placentas • do not allow chronic exposure • nonplacental pharmacokinetic factors |
Chorionic villous explant cultures | • barrier permeability and tissular accumulation of pollutants • impact on cell viability • hormonal production |
• physiological villi • near-physiological 3D microenvironment |
• in vitro • fast ST necrosis • limited time exposures (less than 15 days) |
Primary human trophoblast cultures | • impact on trophoblast viability • hormonal production • cellular internalization of pollutants |
• recapitulate physiological differentiation to form the syncytium • isolation from term and first trimester placentas |
• in vitro • limited period of culture due to cell necrosis • not adapted for chronic exposure |
Cell line cultures | • impact on cell viability • cellular internalization of pollutants • cell signaling and hormonal production |
• low cost • acquired resistance to apoptosis • possible adaptation to long term exposures |
• in vitro • cancerous/immortalized cells’ properties distinct from physiological trophoblasts |
2D co-cultures and placenta-on-a-chip | • barrier permeability and bypassing • impact on cells’ viability • cell signaling and hormonal production |
• near-physiological 3D microenvironment |
• in vitro • cancerous/immortalized cells’ properties distinct from physiological trophoblasts |
3D models (organoids) | still under development | • recapitulate the human placenta villi • anatomically and functionally close to the villous placenta • long term culture possible (chronic exposure possible) |
• in vitro • from first trimester placentas only • the polarity of the organoids (ST within the organoid cavity) needs to be reversed for toxicological studies. |