Table A4.
Study | Country | Aim | Type of Study | Population and Sample | Interventions | Key Findings |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
(Hirvonen et al., 2021) | UK | To understand the perceptions of adolescent students regarding the use of Facebook social media in sexual and reproductive health learning. |
Mixed methods | 1413 teenagers (14 to 16 years) |
Combined interventions: peers’ intervention and use of private Facebook groups |
Social media groups formed around peer supporters’ existing friendship networks hold potential for diffusing messages in peer-based sexual health interventions. |
(Alhassan et al., 2019) | Ghana | To assess mobile phone usage among adolescents and young adult populations pursuing tertiary education and their use of these technologies in the education and prevention of STI. | Quantitative | 250 teenagers (18 to 24 years) |
Mobile phone interventions |
Future mobile phone programs should be considered for STI education and prevention, as they were found to be more comfortable than traditional messaging or phone calls. |
(Cornelius et al., 2019) | USA | To examine adolescents in the USA and Botswana, their mobile phone and social media usage, and their perceptions of safer-sex interventions delivered via social media. |
Qualitative | 28 teenagers (13 to 18 years) | Mobile phone interventions |
Findings provided a starting point for researchers interested in developing a social media intervention with global implications for sexual health promotion. |
(Golbasi and Taskin, 2009) | Turkey | To evaluate the effectiveness of school-based reproductive health education for adolescent girls on the reproductive knowledge level of the girls. | Quasi- experimental |
189 adolescents (age not mentioned) |
Sex education sessions | The school-based program was conducted by nursing educators, and the program was effective in increasing the students’ levels of knowledge on reproductive health. |
(Richards et al., 2019) | Dominican Republic | To evaluate the effectiveness of MAMI’s CSEP in changing knowledge of STIs and pregnancy. | Mixed methods |
600 students aged 11–25 years old |
Multiple interventional program (comprehensive sexual education program: education sessions, interactive activities, visual aids) |
The MAMI’s CSEP improved knowledge of STIs and pregnancy and attitudes toward risky sexual behavior among program recipients. |
(Yakubu et al., 2019) | Ghana | To assess an educational intervention program on knowledge, attitude, and behavior toward pregnancy prevention based on the HBM amongst adolescent girls in Northern Ghana. |
RCT | 363 adolescents (13 to 19 years). |
Sex education sessions | Educational intervention, which was guided by HBM, significantly improved sexual abstinence and the knowledge of adolescents on pregnancy prevention. |
(Aragão et al., 2018) | Brazil | To understand the perceptions of adolescent students regarding the use of Facebook social media in sexual and reproductive health learning. |
Qualitative | 96 adolescents (mean age 15 years) |
Online interventions (Facebook) | Virtual spaces on the Internet offer potential for the production of health care, especially among adolescents, as it contributes to the sexual and reproductive health education in an interactive, playful, and practical way. |
(Bersamin et al., 2018) | USA | To investigate the associations between SBHCs and sexual behavior and contraceptive use among 11th graders. |
Quantitative | 11840 adolescents (average age 16.6) |
Interventions delivered through SBHCs |
Exposure to SBHCs in general, and availability of specific reproductive health services, may be an effective strategy to support healthy sexual behaviors among youth. |
(Hickman and Schaar, 2018) | USA | To develop and evaluate adolescent satisfaction with a text-messaging educational intervention to promote healthy behaviors, reduce the incidence of unhealthy behaviors, and prevent high-risk behaviors. |
Mixed methods | 202 adolescents (14 to 18 years) |
Mobile phone interventions |
Text messaging is a good way to educate adolescents and promote healthy habits, as it shows a high rate of intended behavioral change by adolescents. |
(Beserra et al., 2017) | Brazil | To analyze the perception of adolescents about the life activity “express sexuality”. |
Qualitative | 25 teenagers (15 to 18 years) | Combined interventions: video projection followed by discussion and clarification of doubts |
The use of videos followed by discussion is a valid and useful strategy to help adolescents in expressing their sexuality. |
(Rokicki et al., 2017) | Ghana | To evaluate whether text-messaging programs can improve reproductive health among adolescent girls in low- and middle-income countries. |
RCT | 756 adolescents (14 to 24 years) |
Mobile phone interventions |
Text-messaging programs can lead to large improvements in reproductive health knowledge, and have the potential to lower pregnancy risk for sexually active adolescent girls. |
(Santos et al., 2017) | Brazil | To report the experience of conducting a workshop with teenagers about STIs. | Qualitative | 34 adolescents (average age, 18 years old) | Workshops | Group educational experiences provide adolescents with the opportunity to build shared knowledge, and professionals learn about adolescents’ doubts, and therefore plan new health education meetings. |
(Souza et al., 2017) | Brazil | To describe the online game and reflect on its theoretical– methodological basis. |
Qualitative | 60 adolescents aged 15–18 years |
Online game (Straight Talk) |
Conceived as a pedagogic device, the online game has the capacity to implicate the adolescent in problem-based situations and allows the invention of other forms to deal with sexuality without the demand of support from a teacher. |
(Castillo-Arcos et al., 2016) | Mexico | To evaluate the effect of an internet-based intervention to reduce sexual risk behaviors and increase resilience to sexual risk behaviors among Mexican adolescents. |
Quasi- experimental |
193 adolescents (14 to 17 years) |
Online interventions (sex education sessions) |
The intervention improved self-reported resilience to risky sexual behaviors, though not with a reduction in those behaviors. |
(French et al., 2016) | UK | To explore young people’s views of and experiences with a mobile phone text-messaging intervention to promote safer-sex behavior. | Qualitative | 20 adolescents (16 to 24 years) |
Mobile phone interventions |
The intervention increased knowledge, confidence, and safer-sex behaviors. |
(Grandahl et al., 2016) | Sweden | To improve primary prevention of HPV by promoting vaccination and increased condom use among upper secondary schools. | RCT | 741 adolescents (aged 16 years) |
Sex education sessions (face-to-face structured interventions) | Face-to-face education delivery by health care providers, such as school nurses, is a highly feasible and effective way to increase adolescents’ beliefs and behavior toward primary prevention of HPV, regardless of socioeconomic status, ethnicity, or cultural background. |
(Oliveira et al., 2016) | Brazil | To analyze the limits and the potentialities of the Papo Reto game, for construction of knowledge in the field of sexuality with adolescents. |
Qualitative | 23 adolescents (15 to 18 years) |
Combined interventions (virtual game, workshops) |
The game can be used as a pedagogic device for dealing with the subject of sexuality in adolescents. The results confirmed the potentiality of the contents for dealing with the complexity of reality from the point of view of gender. |
(Rani et al., 2016) | India | To compare the knowledge and attitude regarding pubertal changes among pre-adolescent girls before and after the pubertal preparedness program |
Quasi- experimental |
104 pre- adolescent (12–14 years) |
Sex education sessions | Pubertal preparedness programs and FAQs reinforcement sessions are effective in enhancing knowledge and developing a favorable attitude among pre-adolescent girls. |
(Aventin et al., 2015) | Ireland | To design, develop, and optimize an educational intervention about young men and unintended teenage pregnancy based around an interactive film. |
Mixed methods | 360 adolescents (14 to 17 years) |
Combined interventions: interactive film-based interventions (If I were Jack) with group discussion |
The model of intervention reported in this paper was presented not as an ideal, but as an exemplar that other researchers might utilize, modify, and improve. |
(Enah et al., 2015) | USA | To assess the acceptability and relevance of a web-based HIV prevention game for African American rural adolescents. |
Mixed methods | 42 adolescents (12 to 16 years) |
Online interventions (game: Fast Car) | Using games for HIV prevention was found to be appealing and acceptable, but it was not found to be the best approach to HIV prevention with the target population. |
(Hatami et al., 2015) | Iran | To evaluate the effect of organizing interactions using peer education in schools on the knowledge and attitude toward sexual health. | Quantitative | 282 teenagers (14 to 18 years) |
Peer education | The use of peer education in schools informally could enhance the knowledge and approach toward aspects of physical health, sexual behaviors, and social and mental changes among female adolescents. |
(Jemmott et al., 2015) | 2015 South Africa |
To test the effect of an HIV/STI risk-reduction intervention. | RCT | 1057 adolescents 9–18 years old |
Sex education sessions | The HIV/STI risk-reduction intervention reduced unprotected intercourse and caused positive changes on theoretical constructs. Theory-based behavioral interventions with early adolescents can have long-lived effects in the context of a generalized severe HIV epidemic. |
(Serowoky et al., 2015) | USA | To plan, implement, and evaluate a sustainable model of sexual health group programming (Cuídate) in a high school with a large Latino student population. |
Quasi- experimental |
24 adolescents (13 to 18 years) |
Multiple interventional program (Cuídate) |
The intervention showed significant increases in STI or HIV knowledge, self-efficacy, and intention to use condoms. It can be sustained in a school-based health center with results of efficacy. |
(Elliott et al., 2013) | UK | To assess the effectiveness of the Scottish government’s National Sexual Health Demonstration Project (HR2). |
Quasi- experimental |
5283 pupils aged 15–16 years | Sex education sessions | Combining sex education and sexual health services has a limited impact on young people’s sexual health. |
(Moodi et al., 2013) | Iran | To evaluate the effect of an educational program for puberty health on improving intermediate and high school female students’ knowledge in Birjand, Iran. |
Quasi- experimental |
302 female students (mean age 12.9) | Sex education sessions | Performing educational programs during puberty has a crucial role in young girls’ knowledge increase. |
(Okanlawon and Asuzu, 2013) | Nigeria | To involve adolescents in school-based health-promotion activities that would improve their perception of risk in sexual behavior. |
Quasi- experimental |
519 adolescents |
Peer education |
Adolescents’ active participation in health-promotion activities should be encouraged, as it improves the perception of risk in sexual behavior among adolescents. |
(Valli and Cogo, 2013) | Brazil | To analyze the structure of school blogs on sexuality and their utilization by adolescents. |
Quantitative | 11 blogs about sexuality |
Online interventions (blog) | The blog is a virtual interaction tool common among adolescents that allows the adolescent to establish relationships with other teens interested in the topic, decreasing feelings of doubt, isolation, and shyness. |
(Cornelius et al., 2012) | USA | To understand adolescents’ perceptions of mobile cell phone text-messaging-enhanced and mobile cell phone-based HIV- prevention interventions. |
Qualitative | 11 teenagers (13 to 18 years) | Mobile phone interventions |
The messages increased participants’ HIV awareness and knowledge. |
(Denny et al., 2012) | New Zealand | To determine the association between availability and quality of school health services and reproductive health outcomes among sexually active students. |
Quantitative | 2745 adolescents (13 to 17 years) |
Interventions delivered through SBHCs |
Health services may be able to lower the incidence of pregnancy by providing access to comprehensive health services, including contraceptive care that is easily available and appropriate for the student population. |
(Martyn et al., 2012) | USA | To explore the effects of an event history calendar approach on adolescent sexual risk communication and sexual activity. |
Mixed methods | 30 adolescents (15 to 19 years) |
Event history calendar | School nurses could use the event history calendar approach to improve adolescent communication on sexual risks and tailoring of interventions. |
(Madeni et al., 2011) | Tanzania | To evaluate a reproductive health awareness program for the improvement of reproductive health for unmarried adolescent girls and boys in urban Tanzania. |
Quasi- experimental |
305 adolescents (11 to 16 years) |
Combined interventions (sex education sessions and group discussions) |
The reproductive health program improved the students’ knowledge and behavior about sexuality and decision making after the program for both girls and boys. Their attitudes were not likely to change based on the educational intervention. |
(Fonseca et al., 2010) | Brazil | To find the perception of adolescents on the sexual orientation actions in a public school and to identify the actions’ fragilities and potentials. |
Qualitative | 15 adolescents (15 to 17 years) |
Group discussions | Participative methodology promotes a welcoming and productive work climate and provides larger involvement and learning. |
(Freitas and Dias, 2010) | Brazil | To understand teenagers’ perceptions about the development of their sexuality. |
Qualitative | 12 teenagers (11 to 19 years) | Workshops | Teenagers’ perceptions about their sexuality emerged from the debates and shared knowledge during the workshops. |
(Levandowski and Schmidt, 2010) | Brazil | To enable the exchange of experiences and reflection about sexuality-related actions and choices. |
Qualitative | 270 adolescents (12 to 15 years) |
Workshops | The intervention reduced psychosocial risk factors, providing a healthy development. |
(Villarruel et al., 2010) | Mexico | To examine the effectiveness of a safer-sex program (Cuídate) on sexual behavior, use of condoms, and use of other contraceptives among Mexican youth 48 months after the intervention. |
RCT | 708 adolescents (mean age 19.22) |
Multiple interventional program (Cuídate) |
Results demonstrated the efficacy of Cuídate among Mexican adolescents. Future research, policy, and practice efforts should be directed at sustaining safe-sex practices across adolescents’ developmental and relationship trajectories. |
(Camargo and Ferrari, 2009) | Brazil | To analyze the knowledge of adolescents on sexuality, contraceptive methods, pregnancy, and STDs/AIDS before and after prevention workshops. |
Qualitative | 117 adolescents (14 to 16 years) |
Workshops | There is a need for systematic work, in the medium and long term, in schools regarding adolescent sexuality, as there was no increase in knowledge about STD transmission methods. |
(Gubert et al., 2009) | Brazil | To address the use of educational technology as a strategy for health education among the teenagers in the school. | Qualitative | 30 teenagers (14 to 18 years) | Workshops | Nursing professionals should produce/ readjust new technologies that support the educational process in health education, valuing the skills and aspirations of adolescents, going beyond traditional health education activities based on specific actions and that do not recognize the real needs. |
(Beserra et al., 2008) | Brazil | To investigate the adolescents’ sexuality from the educative action of a nurse in the prevention of STDs. |
Qualitative | 10 adolescents (14 to 16 years) |
Group discussions | The intervention allowed adolescents to explore and discuss many subjects that involved their sexuality, and it was also a moment to take actions on health education with the objective to prevent risks. |
(Gallegos et al., 2008) | Mexico | To test the efficacy of a behavioral intervention designed to decrease risk of sexual behaviors for HIV/AIDS and unplanned pregnancies in Mexican adolescents. |
RCT | 832 adolescents, age 14–17 |
Combined interventions: sex education sessions and interactive games |
The behavioral intervention represented an important effort, and was effective in promoting safe sexual behaviors among Mexican adolescents. |
(Soares et al., 2008) | Brazil | To understand how adolescents live and exercise their sexuality. | Qualitative | 350 adolescents (15 to 19 years) |
Workshops | The workshops favored the discussion of attitude changes in the adolescents through the information, reflection, and expression of ideas and feelings, representing a process to be complemented by the family, school, and local social politics. |
(Henderson et al., 2007) | Scotland | To assess the impact of a theoretically based sex education program (SHARE) delivered by teachers compared with conventional education in terms of conceptions and terminations registered by the NHS. |
RCT | 4196 female (mean age 20) | Multiple intervention program (SHARE) | Enhanced teacher-led school sex education (SHARE) improved knowledge and reduced regret, but did not reduce conceptions or terminations compared with conventional sex education. |
(Tucker et al., 2007) | 2006 UK-Lothian |
To test for improved outcomes for the new Lothian Healthy Respect’s SHARE on teenage sexual behavior outcomes in the Lothian region. |
Quasi- experimental |
4381 secondary school pupils (average age 14.6 years) |
Multiple intervention program (SHARE) | The findings demonstrated limited impact on sexual health behavior outcomes and raised questions about the likely and achievable sexual health gains for teenagers from school-based interventions. |
(Amaral and Fonseca, 2006) | Brazil | To understand adolescents’ social representations on sexual initiation concerning gender. | Qualitative | 16 adolescents (11 to 16 years) |
Workshops | The strategy allowed the understanding of the social representations of teenagers about sexual initiation, being of great importance for planning the work developed with teenagers, supporting debates and reflections on the experience of healthy and responsible sexuality by young people. |
(Beserra et al., 2006) | Brazil | To describe an experience to promote health and prevent STDs among teenagers. |
Qualitative | 28 adolescents (13 to 16 years) |
Workshops | The strategy was effective at promoting teenagers’ adoption of preventative measures. |
(Villarruel et al., 2006) | USA | To test the efficacy of a prevention intervention to reduce sexual risk behavior among Latino adolescents. |
RCT | 553 adolescents, aged 13 to 18 years |
Multiple interventional program (Cuídate) |
Results provided evidence for efficacy for HIV prevention in decreasing sexual activity and increasing condom use among Latino adolescents. |
(Walker et al., 2006) | Mexico | To assess effects on condom use and other sexual behavior of an HIV prevention program at school that promotes the use of condoms with and without emergency contraception. |
RCT | First-year high school students (n = 10954) (16–17 years) |
Sex education sessions | A rigorously designed, implemented, and evaluated HIV education course based in public high schools did not reduce risk behavior, so such courses need to be redesigned and evaluated. |
(Carvalho et al., 2005) | Brazil | To determine how the intervention in sexual guidance was experienced by adolescents. |
Qualitative | 13 adolescents (13 to 15 years) |
Workshops | The analysis demonstrated a reconstruction /redefinition of meaning for the ideas related to sexuality, to gender, and to the wider social context. |
(Barnes et al., 2004) | Australia | To evaluate the impact of changes in the health system and services on the roles and responsibilities of child health nurses and to identify professional development needs. | Qualitative | 10 nurses | Combined interventions: health education and health information displays. |
The school-based youth health nurse program provides nurses with a new, challenging, autonomous role within the school environment, and the opportunity to expand their role to incorporate all aspects of the health-promoting schools’ framework. |
(Stephenson et al., 2004) | UK | To examine the effectiveness of one form of peer-led sex education. | RCT | 8000 students (13 to 14 years) |
Peer education | Peer-led sex education was effective in some ways, but broader strategies are needed to improve young people’s sexual health. The role of single-sex sessions should be further investigated. |
(Lonczak et al., 2002) | USA | To examine the long-term effects of the full SSDP intervention on sexual behavior and associated outcomes assessed at age 21 years. |
Non- randomized controlled trial |
349 former fifth-grade students (aged 21 years) |
Multiple interventional program (SSDP) |
A theory-based social development program that promotes academic success, social competence, and bonding to school during the elementary grades can prevent risky sexual practices and adverse health consequences in early adulthood. |
(Wight et al., 2002) | Scotland | To determine whether a theoretically based sex education program for adolescents (SHARE) delivered by teachers reduced unsafe sexual intercourse compared with current practice. |
RCT | 8430 pupils aged 13–15 years | Multiple intervention program (SHARE) | Compared with conventional sex education, this specially designed intervention did not reduce sexual risk-taking in adolescents. |
(Lieberman et al., 2000) | USA | To assess the impact of an abstinence-based model for sexual education. |
Quantitative | 312 students (mean age 12.9) |
Multiple intervention program (IMPPACT) |
A small-group abstinence-based intervention can have some impact on adolescents’ attitudes and relationships (particularly with their parents). |
(Dunn et al., 1998) | Canada | To evaluate a school-based HIV prevention intervention in adolescents. |
Quasi- experimental |
160 adolescents (14 to 15 years) |
Sex education sessions | School-based interventions can improve adolescents’ short-term HIV/AIDS prevention knowledge, attitudes, self-efficacy, and behavioral intentions. |
(Jemmott III et al., 1998) | USA | To evaluate the effects of abstinence and safer-sex HIV risk-reduction interventions on young inner-city African American adolescent’s HIV sexual risk behaviors when implemented by adult facilitators as compared with peer cofacilitators. |
RCT | 659 adolescents (mean age 11.8) |
Sex education sessions | Both abstinence and safer-sex interventions can reduce HIV sexual risk behaviors, but safer-sex interventions may have longer-lasting effects, and may be especially effective with sexually experienced adolescents. |
(Siegel et al., 1998) | USA | To determine the short-term effect of a middle and high school–based AIDS and sexuality intervention (RAPP) on knowledge, self-efficacy, and behavior intention. |
Non- randomized controlled trial |
Middle and high school students (n = 3635) |
Multiple interventional program (RAPP): games, role playing, take-home exercises |
At short-term follow-up, the RAPP intervention had a powerful effect on knowledge for all students and a moderate effect on sexual self-efficacy and safe behavior intention, particularly for high school students. |
(Stephenson et al., 2008) | UK | To assess the long-term effects of a peer-led sex education program. | RCT | 9000 students (13–14 years) |
Peer education | Compared with conventional school sex education at age 13–14 y, this form of peer-led sex education was not associated with a change in teenage abortions, but may have led to fewer teenage births, and was popular with pupils. It merits consideration within broader teenage-pregnancy- prevention strategies. |