Table 1.
Current protocols employed to decellularize plant material.
Decellularization Treatment | Compounds | Time | Decellularized Plants | Advantages | Limitations |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Chemical | SDS (0.1 to 10%, depending on plant material); Triton X-100; bleach (10%) Hexane pre- treatment can be performed when wax cuticle present | 12 h to 3 weeks, depending on the plant material | Amazon sword [55], Anthurium [35], Anthurium (queen) [35], Apple interior [24,32,33,53,56], Asparagus [56], Bamboo [31,35], Basil [55], Broccoli stem [52,56], Cabbage [57], Calathea zebrina [35], Carrot [52,56], Celery [53,56,58], Cucumber [56], Ficus hispida [59], Garcinia [59], Green onion [56,60], Impatiens capensis [35], Jujube [52], Leek [61], Lucky bamboo [55], Orchid pseudobulb [35], Pachira aquatica [59], Parsley stem [34,58], Peanut hairy root [34], Persimmon [52], Potato [56], Solenostemon “wasabi” [35], Spinach [34,54,55,58,60,62,63], Sweet yellow bell pepper [52], Sweet wormwood [34], summer lilac [35], tomato [55], Ubuçu Palm fibers [64], Vanilla [35] | Gold standard, well characterized; demonstrated ability to decellularize a multitude of plant materials with different structural and chemical compositions | Use of harsh chemicals; potential toxic residue thus, requires intense washing steps; time consuming; chemicals are environmentally toxic [46] |
Detergent-Free [59] | Heated bleach and NaHCO3 solutions or bleach with surfactant | Minutes to hours, depending on the plant material | Bamboo stem, Ficus hispida, Garcinia, Pachira aquatica | Oxidation may enhance cellulose breakdown | Strong chemicals; able to degrade scaffold when heated [59] |
Freeze/Enzymatic [65] | Lyophilization, DNAse I | 24 h | Transgenic plant cultured cell lines: Hairy root, Tobacco bright yellow (BY-2), Monocot rice cells (Oryza sativa L.) | Retains native proteins | Additional clearing with surfactant might be needed to remove debris [1] |
Supercritical Fluid (scCO2) [58] | scCO2 (2500 psi at 33 °C); PAA as cosolvent (2%); bleach if scaffold clearing required; Hexane pre- treatment can be performed when wax cuticle present | 3 h (+6 h if clearing required) | Celery, Parsley stem, Spinach leaf, Sweet mint leaf | Fast; use of soft approach with minimal amount of chemicals; sterilization step included | Needs to be characterized on a larger diversity of plants; specialized equipment required [58] |