Table 1.
First Author | Product | Injection | n | Findings (As Described in the Paper) |
---|---|---|---|---|
Min [32] | ONA | IM | 42 | A significant decrease in sebum production A sebum gradient surrounding the injection point No difference in the efficacy between the 10 units group and the 20 units group Recovery of the sebum production at the 16-week follow-up |
Kondrateva [33] | ONA | IM | 15 | Maximum decrease in sebum production at the 4-week follow-up A return-to-baseline at 16 weeks after injection |
Hathout [30] | ONA | ID | 20 | A significant decrease in sebum production Patient satisfaction up to 3 months Associated improvement in the skin tone and facial pores No influence of age, gender, or skin types |
Shirshakova [31] | ONA | ID | 12 | A decrease of skin surface sebum amount at 1 week and 2 weeks after injection |
Li [19] | MTX | ID | 20 | A marked decrease in sebum production on the BoNTA-treated side in facial seborrhea group |
Rose [2] | ABO | ID | 25 | A significantly lower sebum production at 1, 4, 8, and 12 weeks after injection |
Kesty [34] | ABO | ID | 50 | A significant decrease in sebum production in the treatment groups 30 units and 45 units The effect lasted for 6 months after injection |
ABO: abobotulinumtoxinA (Dysport; Ipsen, Wrexham, UK); ID: intradermal injection; IM: intramuscular injection; MTX: Meditoxin (Medy-Tox Inc., Seoul, Korea); ONA: onabotulinumtoxinA (Botox; Allergan, CA, USA).