Skip to main content
. 2016 Jan 13;2016(1):CD010764. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD010764.pub2

1. Diabetic foot management guidelines and levels of evidence.

Guideline and management recommendations Level of evidence
(According to Oxford Centre for Evidence‐based Medicine ‐ Levels of Evidence (March 2009))
Glycaemic target
National Health and Medical Research Council (NHMRC):  Prevention, identification and management of foot complications in diabetes mellitus 2011
  • Local sharp debridement

  • Topical hydrogel dressings

  • Pressure reduction

  • Offloading

  • Removable offloading

  • Multidisciplinary care management

  • Negative pressure therapy

  • Hyperbaric oxygen

  • Larval therapy

  • Cultured skin equivalents

  • Skin grafting


Note: as per NHMRC levels of evidence
 
Expert opinion
Grade B
Grade B
Grade B
Expert opinion
Grade C
Grade B
Grade B
Grade C
Grade B
Grade D
 
 
Not reported
National Clearinghouse Guidelines  2011
  • Debridement with multidisciplinary team

  • Off‐loading of foot ulcers

  • Pressure relieving support surfaces

  • Negative pressure wound therapy

  • Avoid the use of:

    • dermal or skin substitutes

    • electrical stimulation therapy

    • autologous platelet‐rich plasma gel

    • regenerative wound matrices and dalteparin

    • growth factors

    • hyperbaric oxygen therapy

Not reported HbA1c < 7%
Level B
National Clearinghouse guidelines 2012
(treatment of neuropathic wounds)
  • Assessment by a wound expert

  
 
Grade C
 
National Health Service (NHS): Type 2 diabetes: prevention and management of foot problems 2004
  • Urgent attention within 24 hours

  • Multidisciplinary treatment

  • Multidisciplinary team comprising a podiatrist, orthotists, specialised nurse, diabetologist; with unhindered access to suites for managing major wounds, antibiotic administration, urgent inpatient facilities, community nursing, microbiology and diabetic services

  • Prompt Revascularisation

  • Intensive systemic antibiotic therapy

  • Appropriate wound dressing

  • Close monitoring and regular wound dressing changes

  • Debridement of dead tissue

  • Total contact casting

  • Hyperbaric oxygen, cultured human dermis, topical ketanserin or growth factors

  • Foot care reminders

 
Grade D
Grade D
Grade D
Grade D
Grade C
Grade D
Grade D
Grade B
Grade B
Grade D
Grade B
 
Not reported
 
 
 
National Health Service (NHS): 2011 National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) clinical guideline. Developed by the Centre for Clinical Practice at NICE: Diabetic foot problems: inpatient management of diabetic foot problems
  • Debridement

  • Wound dressings

  • Offloading

  • Antibiotics for infection

  • Timing for surgical management.          

 
 
 
 
Not reported
 
 
 
 
Not reported
2012 International Working Group on Diabetic Foot (IWGDF): Global guideline for type 2 diabetes
  • Local wound care

  • Relief of pressure

  • Treatment of infection

  • Metabolic control

  • Restoration of skin perfusion

 
Not reported
 
 
 
< 8 mmol/l
 
 
 
 
Australian diabetic foot Network: Management of diabetes related foot ulceration ‐ a clinical update
  • Debridement

  • Dressing selection

  • Pressure offloading

  • Management of infection

  • Glycaemic control

  • Multidisciplinary care

 
 
 
Not reported
 
 
 
 Not reported
American College of Foot and Ankle surgeons 2006 (revision): Diabetic foot disorders – a clinical practice guideline
  • Debridement

  • Pressure offloading

  • Treatment of infection

  • Optimise metabolic perturbations

 
 
Not reported
 
 
Not reported
Scottish Intercollegiate Guidelines Network (SIGN) Guidelines 2010
  • Referral to a multidisciplinary care team

  • Total contact casts for unilateral ulcers

  • Irremovable walkers

  • Negative pressure wound therapy

  • Arterial reconstruction for those who require it 

 
Grade C
Grade B
Grade B
Grade B
Grade B
Not reported
American Diabetes Association Standards of Medical Care in Diabetes 2012
  • Multidisciplinary approach

  • Foot ulcers and wound care may require care by a podiatrist, orthopedic or vascular surgeon, or rehabilitation specialist experienced in the management of individuals with diabetes

 
Grade B
Not reported
 
As per position Statement for optimal Control