Skip to main content
. 2021 Nov 29;11:23093. doi: 10.1038/s41598-021-02487-6

Table 7.

Results for assessing publication bias using the Begg’s and Egger’s tests for included studies for different acoustic measures.

Measure Begg’s test Egger’s test
p value Z value p value Bias 95% CI for bias
Pitch range 0.091 1.69 0.062  − 5.31 [− 10.92, 0.29]
Duration 0.118 1.56 0.053  − 3.24 [− 6.53, 0.046]
Intensity 0.324 0.99 0.144  − 4.95 [− 11.85, 1.94]
Mean pitch 0.928 0.09 0.932 0.17 [− 4.01, 4.34]
Pitch standard deviation 0.583 0.55 0.219 3.19 [− 2.19, 8.57]
Pitch variability 0.668 0.43 0.399  − 1.67 [− 5.66, 2.32]
Speech rate 0.734 0.34 0.653 1.72 [− 12.43, 15.78]