Table 1.
Summary of included studies
Author, year | Patients/hips (n) | Age (mean) | M/F (n) |
Body mass index (mean) | Follow-up (years) | Design | MINORS |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Arabmotlag, 200352 | 15/15 | 48 | 7/8 | – | 2 | CTX | 17/22 |
Boller, 201950 | 39/39 | 51 | 13/26 | 28 | 2 | Metha | 12/16 |
28/28 | 66 | 16/12 | 27 | 2 | Metha | ||
Brinkmann, 201541 | 24/24 | 59 | 12/12 | 27 | 1 | Metha | 16/22 |
26/26 | 60 | 16/10 | 27 | Nanos | |||
Ercan, 201642 | 62/62 | 57 | 28/34 | 29 | 1 | Minihip | 10/16 |
Fokter, 201524 | 19/19 | 60 | 8/11 | 28 | 1 | Unibionix | 16/22 |
Freitag, 201633 | 57/57 | 57 | 36/21 | 30 | 1 | Fitmore | 19/22 |
Gasbarra, 201434 | 33/33 | 62 | 15/18 | 24 | 1 | Fitmore | 16/22 |
Hayashi, 201670 | 21/21 | 68 | 11/56 | 23 | 2 | Trilock | 12/16 |
Jahnke, 201443 | 40/40 | 55 | 20/20 | 27 | 1 | Metha | 13/16 |
Kim, 201125 | 50/60 | 54 | 22/28 | 26 | 3 | Proxima | 16/22 |
50/60 | 52 | 24/26 | 25 | Profile | |||
Kim, 201626 | 201/221 | 53 | 118/83 | 30 | 10 | Proxima | 19/22 |
400/530 | 53 | 264/136 | 29 | IPS | |||
Kim, 201636 | 200/200 | 53 | 138/62 | 30 | 12 | Proxima | 19/22 |
200/200 | 53 | 138/62 | 30 | Profile | |||
Leali, 200427 | 10/10 | 65 | 4/6 | – | 3 | Revelation | 10/16 |
Lerch, 201244 | 25/25 | 59 | 16/9 | 25 | 2 | Metha | 13/16 |
Meyer, 201932* | 54/54 | – | – | – | 5 | Fitmore | – |
Nysted, 201151 | 43/43 | 55 | 18/28 | – | 5 | Unique | 16/22 |
35/35 | 53 | 13/28 | – | ABG-I | |||
Panisello, 200937 | 56/56 | 60 | 27/29 | 28 | 5 | ABG-I | 19/22 |
54/54 | 59 | 26/28 | 27 | ABG-II | |||
Parchi, 201749 | 20/20 | 54 | 11/9 | – | 4 | Metha | 12/16 |
Rahmy, 200438 | 24/24 | 62 | 11/18 | 28 | 3 | ABG-I | 18/22 |
Salemyr, 201531 | 26/26 | 62 | 11/15 | 27 | 4 | Proxima | 21/22 |
Shafy, 201645 | 26/26 | 43 | 20/6 | 27 | 2 | Minihip | 12/16 |
Sluimer, 200628 | 40/40 | 53 | 15/25 | – | 2 | Omnifit-HA 1090 | 18/22 |
Steens, 201546 | 20/20 | 49 | 12/8 | 26 | 5 | ESKA cut 2000 | 14/16 |
Synder, 201547 | 36/36 | 50 | 18/18 | – | 1 | Metha | 12/16 |
Vd Wal, 200640 | 25/25 | 62 | 17/8 | – | 2 | ABG-I | 16/22 |
26/26 | 60 | 12/14 | – | 2 | ABG-II | ||
Vd Wal, 200839 | 24/24 | 60 | 11/13 | – | 2 | ABG-I | 15/22 |
White, 200829 | 27/27 | 37 | 14/13 | 25 | 5 | Epoch | 9/16 |
Wixson, 199730 | 35/35 | 50 | 16/19 | – | 2 | Custom made | 9/16 |
Zeh, 201348 | 25/25 | 60 | 15/10 | 29 | 1 | Nanos | 11/16 |
Note. MINORS, Methodological Index for Non-Randomized Studies.
*Study between two age groups.
**follow-up of Freitag et al, 201633.