Table 1.
Author, year (reference number, companion articles) | Study design, Location | Rural characteristics (definition or classification, % of sample) | Sample characteristics (analytic sample size, target population, descriptives) | Intervention (description, setting, duration, contact number and time) | Physical activity measure (units), Timing of assessments | Summary of findings |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Befort, et al., 2012 [36] | Single arm trial Kansas, United States | Three cancer centers located in towns with population size 20,000-47,000 Participants resided in RUCA-defined rural area 100% rural | N=31 Rural postmenopausal breast cancer survivors who had completed treatment 100.0% female 97.0% white 26.0% high school degree or less M age=58.9 years | Group-based weight control intervention including aerobic and strength-training activities delivered via conference call Sessions held once/week for 24 weeks (1440 min) | Minnesota Physical Activity Questionnaire (kcal/week or min/week) 0 and 24 weeks | Physical activity increased by 196.5 min/week over 24 weeks 71% of those who completed the intervention met physical activity goal of 225 min/week |
Eakin, et al., 2012 [40, 56] | Randomized controlled trial Queensland, Australia | Participants resided within a postal code considered inner regional, outer regional, remote or very remote based on their Australian Standard Geographical Classification 100% rural | N=137a Rural women diagnosed with invasive breast cancer and treated at one of 8 regional or 4 large metropolitan hospitals 100% female 53.1% less than high school M age=52.9 years | Exercise for Health-rural (EfH) telephone-delivered mixed (aerobic and resistance) exercise intervention Participants received an exercise workbook and 16 calls over 32 weeks (480 min) | Active Australia Survey (min/week) and CHAMPS questionnaire (strength-training sessions/week) were used to calculate % meeting aerobic (≥4 times/week and ≥180 min of MVPA/week) and resistance training (≥2 sessions/week) goals 0, 24, and 48 weeks | 45.6% of EfH participants met their resistance training goal compared to 10.4% of control participants at 24 weeks and 40.3% vs. 17.9% met their goal at 48 weeks No statistically significant between group differences for aerobic activity |
Fazzino, et al., 2017 [37, 57–59] | Phase 1: Single arm trial Phase 2: Randomized controlled trial Rural areas of the midwestern United States (Kansas, Nebraska, and Iowa) | Participants resided in a rural area defined by RUCA Codes, Urban Influence Codes, amount of agricultural income, and/or individual commuting patterns 100% rural | N=142 Rural postmenopausal breast cancer survivors who had completed treatment 100.0% female 97.0% white 23.0% high school degree or less M age=58.6 years | Phase 1: 6-month weight loss phase where all participants receive group-based phone counseling Sessions held once/week for 26 weeks (1560 min) Phase 2: 12-month maintenance phase where participants are randomized to continued group phone-based or mailed newsletter comparison group Group-based phone counseling sessions held biweekly (1560 min) and newsletters mailed biweekly | GT3X+ Actigraph accelerometer (bouted MVPA min/week) and the Paffenbarger Physical Activity Questionnaire (MVPA min/week) 0, 26, 52, and 78 weeks | Phase 1: Accelerometer-(46.9 min/week) measured and self-reported (227.5 min/week) MVPA increased from 0 to 26 weeks Phase 2: Accelerometer-measured (−27.2 min/week) and self-reported (−77.5 min/week) MVPA decreased from 26 to 78 weeks |
Frensham, et al., 2020 [41, 60, 61] | Quasi-randomized controlled trial Rural regions of south Australia | Not specified 47.3% ruralb | N=91 Metropolitan and rural Australians diagnosed with cancer (any type except skin) who had completed treatment and were insufficiently active 51.6% female 95.6% white 72.5% less than high school M age=65.7 years | STRIDE (Steps Toward Improving Diet and Exercise for cancer survivors) web-based intervention including aerobic activity or waitlist control Participants access STRIDE website for 12 weeks and are emailed daily step goals weekly | New-Lifestyles NL-1000 pedometer (steps/day) 0, 12, and 24 weeks | STRIDE intervention group increased their daily steps/day by 31.5% compared with an increase of 12.5% in the control group |
Gray, et al., 2019 [38, 62–64] | Secondary analysis of a randomized controlled trial North Carolina and rural regions across the United States | RUCA defined large rural, small rural, and isolated regions 100% rural | N=160 Rural elderly colorectal, breast, and prostate cancer survivors who were ≥5 years post-diagnosis and insufficiently active 56.9% female 86.9% white 38.1% high school or less M age=73.0 years | Reach-out to Enhance Wellness (RENEW) iteratively-tailored behavioral intervention including mailed print materials, telephone prompts, and telephone counseling or delayed intervention Participants were contacted 28 times across the 48 week intervention period | Community Health Activities Model Program for Seniors (CHAMPS) questionnaire, endurance (min/week) and strength-training (min/week) exercise 0 and 48 weeks | Endurance exercise increased by 27.1 min/week and strength-training exercise increased by 22.7 min/week over 48 weeks (greater changes in physical activity observed in urban vs. rural, but no statistically significant difference between groups) |
Hegel, et al., 2011 [39] | Randomized controlled trial Rural New Hampshire, United States | Not specified 100% rural | N=23 Rural breast cancer patients undergoing adjuvant therapy at the Norris Cotton Cancer Center 100% female 100% white 66% bachelor degree M age=52.6 years | Telephone-delivered problem solving and occupational therapy (PST-OT) intervention or usual care Sessions delivered once a week for 6 weeks (246 min) | Adherence to aerobic exercise (measure and units not specified) 0, 6, and 12 weeks | No differences between groups in the frequency of engaging in aerobic exercise |
Ristevsk, et al., 2020 [42] | Single arm trial Victoria, Australia | Rural region in eastern Victoria (West Gippsland), which has a population of 52,105 distributed over 4025 km2 and has one public acute hospital 100% rural | N=48b Rural adults diagnosed with cancer who were admitted to the chemotherapy day unit 71% female M age=65.9 years | I.CAN program uses a health coaching model to provide tailored nutrition and physical activity guidance via three streams: One-on-one support (Stream A), combination of one-on-one support and group sessions (Stream B), and group sessions (Stream C) One on one support and group sessions held fortnightly for 6 weeks (390 min) | Godin Leisure Time Exercise Questionnaire (% meeting guidelines) 0, 12, 24, and 48 weeks | % meeting exercise guidelines increased from 51% to 86% over 12 weeks |
Abbreviations: M, mean; MVPA, moderate-to-vigorous physical activity
Race/ethnicity and/or education not reported.
Unable to calculate results for rural sample only.